IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

McCarthy readies plan to kick Schiff off House Intelligence panel

The fact that Kevin McCarthy intends to punish Adam Schiff is a problem. The minority leader’s rationale makes the problem quite a bit worse.

By

It’s a little too soon to say with confidence what will happen in the fall’s midterm elections, but House Republicans aren’t making much of an effort to hide their optimism. In fact, GOP leaders are already drawing up plans on what they’ll do with power.

Evidently, kicking House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff off the powerful panel is on the list. The conservative Washington Times reported:

House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy plans to eject Rep. Adam Schiff from his seat on the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence if Republicans take back the majority in November. Mr. McCarthy, California Republican, accused Mr. Schiff, a California Democrat who currently chairs the Intelligence Committee, of “politicizing” the panel and not paying attention to the threats against the U.S.

After making some strange comments about Hunter Biden’s laptop — yes, this is apparently a popular topic again in Republican circles — the would-be House Speaker shared a little rant about Schiff during a Capitol Hill press conference.

“Why is he still chair of the committee? And why is he even on the committee?” McCarthy asked rhetorically. “In a new Congress, if it’s a new majority, he will not be. You cannot make this committee political.”

Let’s unpack this a bit because it’s likely to be important. There are three elements to the story that are worth keeping in mind.

First, there’s little to suggest Schiff has done what McCarthy has accused him of doing. To hear the minority leader tell it, the California Democrat has both “lied” and “politicized” the intelligence committee. He’s actually done neither.

Second, if McCarthy is concerned about the politicization of the House Intelligence panel, I’d love to introduce the minority leader to Devin Nunes — who, during his tenure as Schiff’s predecessor, literally held secret meetings at the Trump White House as part of a ham-fisted political scheme.

And third, it ordinarily wouldn’t matter whether one party’s leadership doesn’t like another party leadership’s committee assignments. If Schiff wants to remain on the House Intelligence Committee in the next Congress, he’d need the support of Democratic leaders, not GOP leaders.

So why is McCarthy vowing to remove Schiff from the key panel? Because as far as Republicans are concerned, Democrats effectively rewrote the rules when they stripped two far-right congressional extremists — Reps. Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia and Paul Gosar of Arizona — of their committee assignments.

As far as McCarthy and other GOP leaders are concerned, this opened the flood gates: If Democrats can make such decisions about Greene and Gosar, then Republicans can make related decisions about Schiff — and presumably any other Democrat who annoys the right.

The problem, to the extent that reality matters, is that Gosar and Greene were punished for a specific reason: They’re members who were accused of espousing violence. Democrats didn’t change the rules so much as they set a standard: To talk of political violence is to cross an important line.

What McCarthy described on Friday is something different: To reject conspiracy theories about Hunter Biden’s laptop is also to cross a line.

Related: