Killing of George Floyd TRANSCRIPT: 5/28/20, The Rachel Maddow Show
PAUL BUTLER, AUTHOR, “CHOKEHOLD”: And so, that doesn`t need to happen. We
need to change the law. We need to understand that the real crisis isn`t
what`s going on in the streets tonight in Minneapolis, the real crisis is
that the streets have never been safe for black people and brown people in
CHRIS HAYES, MSNBC HOST, “ALL IN”: Phillip Atiba Goff, Paul Butler, thank
you, gentlemen, both, for sharing that. Appreciate it.
That is “ALL IN” for this evening.
THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW starts right now.
Good evening, Rachel.
RACHEL MADDOW, MSNBC HOST: Good evening, Chris. Thanks, my friend.
And thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. This has been just a
remarkable day in the news today. And I don`t mean that in a good way. I
almost never do.
Today, we got word that for a tenth straight week, millions of Americans
have filed for unemployment. In the past week, the record before this
pandemic crisis was like 600,000-something Americans applying for
unemployment in one week, in the depths of the great recession and frankly
a number like 600,000-something would be spectacular news for us at this
point. For us now, week after week, I said ten weeks, actually for eight
straight weeks as of today, we are over two million Americans filing for
Simultaneously, and perhaps in a related development, the White House
announced today that they`re just not going to give their annual national
forecast for the economy this summer. The White House does that every year.
They do a budget in February and then they do an economic forecast in the
summer for how things are going to go for the rest of the year.
Except this year, for the first time in decades, they`ve just said they`re
not going to do that. Better not to say, right? Imagine what that report
would say about the forecast for the economy, if they did have to put it
out. Better just to keep mum maybe.
We are learning from this federal government with each passing day of the
epidemic that not talking about something terrible is at least to their
mind the easiest way to pretend that that terrible thing just isn`t
happening. Smiles, everyone. Smile, everyone. Fantasy island.
In terms of the epidemic, and its progress, this week has seen a whole
bunch of states start to hit record numbers in terms of the number of
hospital beds that are being occupied by COVID-19 patients. We`ve got
record hospitalization numbers right now, in Kentucky, and in Arizona, and
in Alabama, and in North Carolina, in the state of Arkansas, the state
health director warned today that they`re heading toward a new record peak
in hospitalizations in Arkansas, as well. In the great state of Minnesota,
they not only are at their highest rate of hospitalizations yet, the Twin
Cities area, Minneapolis, St. Paul is up near 90 percent full in terms of
its ICU beds already, and the state today just announced that they have hit
their highest one-day death toll for coronavirus as well.
Minnesota is just dealing with a bare of an epidemic with the numbers going
the wrong way, with hospitalization and ICU numbers getting troubling,
particularly in the Twin Cities. And now, of course, Minneapolis,
particularly the Twin Cities area, is dealing with a whole other layer of
crisis on top of that.
Tonight, as we`ve been covering here intensively on MSNBC, the eyes of the
nation are on Minnesota, and Minneapolis is still reeling tonight,
following the death on Monday night of an unarmed 46-year-old African-
American man named George Floyd who died in police custody. Mr. Floyd was
seen on tape repeatedly pleading that he couldn`t breathe, as an officer
pinned him to the ground with his knee, jammed into Mr. Floyd`s neck for
minute after minute after minute after minute.
Since the day after George Floyd died, protests have been taking place
throughout Minneapolis and in other cities across the country, too. These
are live images that you`re looking at right now in terms of what is going
on in Minneapolis tonight as we head toward nightfall.
The neighboring city of Saint Paul, which is, of course, the capital city
of Minnesota, they ordered the state capital evacuated today. They ordered
everybody out of the state capital, to get out, there were violent protests
today in Saint Paul. This video was shot by an NBC News crew outside a
Target store where hundreds of protesters were gathered and police were
called after reports of looters at the shop having it and after police
arrived, demonstrators were seen pelting a squad car with rocks and later
took a bat to that squad car. There`s no officer in the squad car. Just the
car itself is being barbed up and smashed there.
Shopping carts were later thrown at police vehicles on that same scene, as
officers tried to form a wall in front of that store front. A reporter for
our local affiliate that officers did eventually use tear gas against that
The looting that has been seen so far has led some Minneapolis businesses
to put up signs in their windows that say minority-owned, in the hopes that
they will be spared from looting. This all comes after a particularly
confrontational chaotic and at times violent night last night. I mean,
yesterday`s protests in Minneapolis did begin peacefully but things
escalated over the course of the night and into the night and in the early
morning, a standoff outside the city`s third police precinct, eventually
within hours spilled over into chaos and some nearby businesses being
looted and other nearby businesses being burnt to the ground.
At this particular intersection, we can show you an apartment development
was under construction was completely destroyed after it was set on fire.
Some firefighters were attacked as they arrived to put out various fires in
the city. Authorities made the decision to just let some buildings burn
rather than risk firefighters being injured or worse. Police officers fired
tear gas at protesters and also rubber bullets.
Tonight, Minnesota`s governor, Tim Walz, has activated the natural guard in
Minnesota to come in and help state police and local police with the
situation on the ground. He has declared a state of emergency in the Twin
So, tonight, there is a lot of worry, there is a lot of consternation about
what may happen next. Violence is obviously not the whole story here,
throughout this whole or deal, we`ve also seen so many images of just plain
grief, and anger and upset that`s not expressed violently.
Grief in a city trying to come together, and trying to figure out how to
move past yet another incident like this, we`ve seen that in makeshift
memorials throughout the city. We saw it today, at a vigil held by our own
colleague, Reverend Al Sharpton, you know the site where George Floyd was
arrested, on Monday night. We also saw it at a massive peaceful protest
this evening outside of Minneapolis City Hall, where people chanted, say
his name, George Floyd. Say his name, George Floyd.
The overarching sentiment from those crowds today is they want to know if
justice will be served. So far again, this killing, in police custody,
happened on Monday night. It is now Thursday. The officers in this case,
four officers, who were on the scene of the arrest have all been fired.
It`s been reported tonight that they have all invoked their Fifth Amendment
rights against self incrimination. It remains to be seen what charges if
any will be filed against those officers.
Earlier in the day today, the federal Justice Department said that they
have made an investigation into Floyd`s death a top priority and with the
Justice Department nobody quite knows what that means.
The Hennepin County district attorney today asked for patience as his
office examines the case and considers whether or not the charges will be
The mayor of Minneapolis, Jacob Frey, is meanwhile trying to hold his city
together as the whole country looks at Minneapolis tonight, basically just
holding our breath.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
MAYOR JACOB FREY (D), MINNEAPOLIS, MN: If you`re feeling that sadness, that
anger, it`s not only understandable, it`s right. It`s a reflection of the
truth that our black community has lived. While not from lived experience,
that sadness must also be understood by our non-black communities.
I believe in Minneapolis. I love Minneapolis. And in believing in our city,
we must believe that we can be better than we have been.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: Joining us now, exclusively for the interview tonight, is Jacob
Frey, the mayor of Minneapolis.
Mr. Mayor, I know this is a really, really difficult time. Thanks for
taking time to be here with us tonight.
FREY: Thank you so much for having me, Rachel.
Before we get going –
MADDOW: Obviously –
MADDOW: Please go ahead.
FREY: Yes, before we get going, I did want to address things after what
transpired last night, and I have a very simple message for residents and
community members within our city, that we need peace. If you are feeling
anger, or sadness, I get it. It is not only understandable, it is – it is
But we cannot allow that anger and sadness to so negatively impact our
communities. We can`t be looting some of the community institutions that we
need the most right now, especially during a pandemic. We need grocery
stores for food. We need pharmacies for medicine. We need banks for cash.
And these institutions are all the more important, especially in our low
income communities. So, by all means, protest, express your First Amendment
rights, we will stand up for them. But we do need peace as well in our
MADDOW: Mr. Mayor, today, when you said I believe in Minneapolis but also
that the city must be better than we have been – I wanted to give you a
chance to address that, too. And what do you think that means in concrete
terms for your city, in terms of what needs to be better, what needs to be
fixed, and what would count as justice in this case?
FREY: Well, Rachel, we`re not just talking about five horrid minutes of
mistreatment of our black community, and specifically of George Floyd,
we`re talking about 400 years worth of institutionalized racism. We`re
talking about intentional segregation and restrictive covenants that run
with the land and disparities in health and income and water and treatment
– pretty much every single facet of life.
And so, this particular five minutes stands on a very long history of
wrongful conduct, and we do need to be better. We need to acknowledge it.
We need to embrace that reality. And then we need – we need action, you
And the first action that I believe needs to come is the charge. We need a
charge of the arresting officer in this case.
You know, there was every incentive for me not to speak out about this
issue. You know, there are all sorts of precautions and protocols that are
baked into the walls of city hall that will tell you not to say something,
not to act too soon, follow the process.
But like this was an instance when, you know, honesty is so important,
because it`s the only way that we`re really going to move forward.
MADDOW: You just made an impassioned call for peace in the streets of
Minneapolis tonight, as people are gathering once again to protest. Can you
give us an update on the situation on the ground, and the plans tonight in
terms of how to try to protect life and property as we head into the
FREY: I`ve been in constant contact with our police chief, as well as our
governor and I`m very appreciative of the resources they have been able to
provide. And I also want to note that we have a whole lot of people, as a
matter of fact, we`ve got a thousand people who are downtown right now that
are protesting so peacefully. And we want to protect them. They need to be
speaking out right now, because ultimately, that voice will improve our
community for the long haul.
But, you know, in an era of sound bites, so often, those that are
protesting peacefully get lumped in with those that are not. You know,
officers that are operating compassionately get lumped in with those that
And we need to be clear about what we are saying right now, which is by all
means, like anger makes sense, sadness makes sense, but I think right now,
like I said, what we need is some action right now, and that starts with of
course terminations which we`ve already done as all four officers have been
term terminated. And I`ve also called on the county attorney to move
forward with the charge.
I spent, you know, the better part of 36 hours asking myself a very simple
question, which is why is the officer that pressed his knee into the neck
of a helpless black man that was unarmed and handcuffed, why is that
officer not in jail? Why has he not been charged?
And, you know, I couldn`t answer that question, Rachel, because if you had
done that, or if I had done that, we would be in jail.
And so, of course, I understand the need for investigation. But I do also
believe fully that we need to charge.
MADDOW: Do you have any indication of when that charging decision might be
We heard the Hennepin County Attorney Mike Freeman today ask for patience,
basically saying that this needs to be – this is a decision that can`t be
rushed. We also saw the federal Justice Department come in and say this
will be a top priority for the department. We also saw the medical examiner
say that they`re waiting for the results of the laboratory testing,
relating to the autopsy before they`re willing to say anything about the
cause of death.
What`s your sense about the pace which these developments are likely to
roll out? I`m thinking about that not just in terms of interest of the
process, but I think it`s going to have a big impact in terms of whether or
not people feel the need to continually night after night get back out into
FREY: You`re absolutely right. And that`s precisely the conflict that we`re
dealing with right now. And I understand the necessity of having a thorough
investigation. And I understand the need to make sure that, you know, all
evidence is reviewed.
I also understand what I saw. And I saw the video that everyone else did.
And what I saw was again five minutes worth of horrid conduct that is just
wrong at the most human level. When someone is calling out for help, it`s
our obligation to help them, especially if you`re an officer that is
charged with protecting and serving the public.
That didn`t happen. And that`s a failure.
MADDOW: One of the things that will be different tonight and heading into,
I guess heading into the next few days, is that the National Guard has been
called up in the state. The governor has declared a state of emergency.
I understand that you may have had a role in advising the governor that it
would be – that it would be worth it to call up the National Guard.
Can you give us any insight into that decision process, and whether you`re
at all concerned that having that different kind of authority present,
having the guard working alongside state troopers and police, could be
something that could be seen as further escalating tensions or further
hardening the line between the community and the authorities that they`re
so mad at right now?
FREY: We did think long and hard about this as well. I had many
conversations with the governor to ensure that the presence is one of
peace. The presence is one to protect these necessary community members,
and community assets that have become all the more vital, because we`re
operating two different crises right now, I mean, we`re sandwiched between
COVID-19 in which we, of course, declared a state of emergency, and this
And that combination, yes, you know, we do need first responders, we do
need to make sure that our city is protected, and we can make sure that
those National Guard members that are in our city are positioned, not as an
occupying force, but one to protect these necessary assets of our
MADDOW: Are you at all worried that the crowds in the streets are – I
mean, we are looking at live images right now, lots of people, if not the
vast majority of the people we`re looking at are wearing masks but not
everybody. Of course, people are not six feet apart from one another for
the most part and these are chaotic, if outdoor gatherings that are
happening, are you worried that these two crises may dovetail in terms of
the risk of transmission at these ongoing protests?
FREY: Yes, if you`re not worried about that right now, then you`re not
human. Of course, yes, I`m very concerned.
You know, we have seen the number of cases going up. We did a whole lot of
work in Minneapolis, in Minnesota, to elongate that curve so that we didn`t
hit the peak early on, when we didn`t have the necessary ICU capacity, and
ventilators necessary to accommodate what would inevitably come in terms of
But yes, there is – there`s definitely a concern about hitting that peak
in the nearer future, as we know that there are a lot of people that are
And so, you know, by all means, again, express your First Amendment rights.
Please, though, you know, wear a mask, stay at least six feet apart, and,
you know, it`s about who we are in this city, you know? A lot of the people
who are protesting right now may not be that high risk, but it`s about
looking at the rest of our community that may be high risk. And that`s why
we`re wearing masks and we`re taking these necessary precautions now.
MADDOW: Mayor Jacob Frey of Minneapolis – sir, I know you have a heck of a
night ahead of you, sir. Good luck to you and your city. Come back as this
story unfolds. The whole country is pulling for you.
FREY: Thank you so much, Rachel.
MADDOW: All right. The protests that we have seen in Minneapolis Tuesday
night, Wednesday night, tonight, calling for justice for George Floyd, have
been spread out now beyond Minnesota and across the country. Last night
while protesters in Minneapolis and saint Paul are demonstrating through
the night, sometimes fighting tear gas and rubber bullets in clashes with
the police, protesters in California also marched in downtown Los Angeles.
They blocked the 101 Freeway, completely shutting down traffic at one point
by forming a human chain. Protesters eventually clashed with police there,
Some of the protesters shattered the windows of a California highway patrol
vehicle. One protester sitting on top of a California highway patrol
vehicle, was injured, getting knocked off that car, as it sped away.
In Memphis, Tennessee, a group of more than 70 people marched down union
everybody in Midtown Memphis last night, eventually linking arms and
blocking that avenue as well, they were out there for four hours. Memphis
police made five arrests last night.
In Michigan, people gathered at the capitol building in Lansing to listen
to speech, to offer prayers for the family of George Floyd.
And today, there has been more. Today, in New York City, protesters in
Union Square, in Manhattan, chanted I can`t breathe and we need justice, as
they stood face to face with NYPD officers. So far, more than two dozen
people have been arrested in New York.
There are also huge demonstrations in Chicago today. Dozens of people
marching down Halsted Street in Chicago South Side, carrying signs that
said, no lives matter until black lives matter, and we demand police
And in Alabama, a group gathered today at a park in downtown Birmingham to
sing and mourn and protest together.
Protesters in Denver, Colorado, gathered at the state capitol, and marched
downtown, demanding justice for George Floyd. Breonna Taylor, who was shot
to death by police on March 13th in her home in Kentucky. Sean Reed, who
was shot and killed by an officer in Minneapolis on May 7th.
These protests are spreading to every corner of the country but they began
this week in Minneapolis and they continue in Minneapolis tonight, and
we`re going to get more reporting from the heart of that great city as we
head into nightfall tonight, just ahead.
Stay with us.
MADDOW: Well, while the eyes of the nation are on Minneapolis tonight,
you`re forgiven if you feel like there is something familiar in these
scenes. That`s because the streets of Minneapolis have seen large, intense
extended forecasts over this police department over the past few years.
When police officers shot and killed Jamar Clark, an unarmed 24-year-old
black man in November 2015, that sparked days of intense protests in
Minneapolis, including makeshift encampment outside the fourth police
precinct in Minneapolis. Protesters stayed at that encampment for 18 days.
Justice for Jamar.
A Justice Department review was later sharply critical of the Minneapolis
city government and police chief for mishandling those protests. Both the
county attorney and the U.S. Justice Department though declined to bring
charges against the two officers who were involved in Jamar Clark`s death.
Just a few months after that decision to not charge those two officers, a
man named Philando Castile, a cafeteria supervisor at a school in Saint
Paul was shot and killed by a police officer during what seemed like a
routine traffic stop. Castile`s girlfriend was in the car with him during
that traffic stop. She live-streamed the incredibly terrifying aftermath of
that shooting from her phone. Her 4-year-old daughter was in the backseat
of the car during that shooting.
And the protests that followed the acquittal of the officer who shot
Philando Castile, hundreds of demonstrators at one point blocked a major
freeway and protests were large and intense in Minneapolis.
Just one month after that protest, there was another Minneapolis police
officer who shot and killed Justine Damond, an unarmed woman who had called
911, to report a possible assault. Now, in that case, the officer was
arrested, tried and convicted of third degree murder and manslaughter. But
in that case, the officer who pulled the trigger was black. And the victim,
Justine Damond was white.
Those three high profile fatal shootings by Minneapolis police, three
shootings of that high profile, in less than two years, and the huge
protests in that city, that led to the resignation of the Minneapolis
police chief, that also contributed to the city`s last mayor losing re-
election, and we just spoke with the current mayor of Minneapolis, Jacob
Frey, the current police chief is not only the city`s first black police
chief he was one of five high ranking police officers who sued the
department alleging institutional racism.
He has had his work cut out for him to try to reform this troubled police
department. One of the white police officer`s whose hostile actions in the
2007 lawsuit went on to become the head of the Minneapolis police union and
known for things calling Black Lives Matter a terrorist organization in the
wake of the Jamar Clark killing and also known for paling around for
President Trump and his homemade Cops for Trump T-shirt at a rally in
Minneapolis last fall.
It is all that roiling history, much of it very, very recent history that
is undergirding everything that is happening right now in Minneapolis. It
is just one example of how radio active the Minneapolis Police Department
has become. You should know that the University of Minnesota, the state`s
flagship university, today they announced they are cutting ties with
Minneapolis police. They will no longer contract with police in Minneapolis
for big events, for football game, graduation ceremonies, they don`t want
anything to do with the Minneapolis PD.
Joining us now, once again, is Brandt Williams. He`s a reporter covering
the story for Minnesota Public Radio. He was with us here last night. I
asked him to come back as this story develops and boy is the story
Mr. Williams, I really appreciate you coming back and talk to us tonight.
Thanks for being here.
BRANDT WILLIAMS, MINNESOTA PUBLIC RADIO: No problem. Thanks for having me
MADDOW: So tell me where you are, and what you`ve seen, and how things on
the ground tonight compare with what we`ve seen the past couple of nights.
WILLIAMS: Well, tonight, as you can see behind me, the building, to my,
over my shoulder there is the Hennepin government center. This is the site
of a large and a peaceful protest, it started a couple of hours ago, the
folks have gathered around 5:00, they started chanting, talking about
George, and I`m sorry, George Floyd, and saying his name over and over,
saying that they want justice for George, and they have done a couple of
marches around downtown.
Over my shoulder, I don`t know if you can tell, but. So folks have now
started some, to do another march, they`re going around, and conducting
some more chants, you can hear horns honking. And – but overall, unlike
the scene last night outside the third precinct, this has been very
MADDOW: Brandt, let me ask you, in terms of Hennepin County attorney, one
of the things we talked about last night and one of the things that is a
real point of focus is the question of whether or not any of these officers
are going to be charged. Now, Mike Freeman, the county attorney, said today
he needs patience, this is going to take some time. He also put out a call
for additional evidence, particularly any additional video evidence from
any additional witnesses.
From your history, covering these sorts of things and from looking at this
situation right now is, that an unusual request? Is that, how is that going
over, given the video evidence that everybody has seen that already exists
of this arrest and Mr. Floyd`s death?
WILLIAMS: Well, you know, I wouldn`t say necessarily that`s unusual, for
the Hennepin County attorney`s office. You touched on the previous
shooting, that particular prosecution took a long time to get from the
investigation to a charging decision. And during that period, there was a
back and forth between the county attorney`s office, and members of the
Minneapolis police department.
There was allegations that police officers were not cooperating with that
investigation and there had been some bad blood between members of the
police department, and the Hennepin county attorney`s office which is
remarkable because these two entities usually have to work very closely
together in order to get prosecutions.
Now I also covered another case of the Minneapolis police officer who was
tried and convicted for assault while on duty, and during that trial, that
officer`s name was Christopher Reiter (ph), and during that trial, there
was tension between the police officers who were testifying, on behalf of
the prosecution, during the trial. They were visibly reluctant to testify.
And so, it sounds to me that this may be another one of those situations
where Freeman is trying to shore up as much evidence as he can, before he
decides to make some sort of charging decision, because it`s going to be a
tough call, either way, because the police are going to fight him, likely
on operating of the prosecution of one of their own, and if he doesn`t
decide to prosecute, what the community response is going to be.
MADDOW: Brandt Williams, reporter of Minnesota Public Radio, out in the
thick of it tonight in downtown Minneapolis – sir, thank you again for
taking time to talk to us. We will be coming back to you in coming days as
this develops. Thanks again.
Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey was joined at his press conference today, in a
very dramatic moment by the vice president of the Minneapolis city council.
Her name is Andrea Jenkins. And when she stepped up to the microphone today
with the mayor at this press conference, this is what happened. It was a
very, very dramatic moment.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
(SINGING “AMAZING GRACE”)
ANDREA JENKINS, MINNEAPOLIS CITY COUNCIL VICE PRESIDENT: We feel as if
there was a knee on all of our collective necks. A knee that says black
life does not matter, to the institutions that dictate what happens in this
culture and society.
I am a part of this system to help to take that knee off of our necks.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: She is the vice president of the Minneapolis city council, Andrea
Jenkins. Ms. Jenkins is the nation`s first openly transgender black woman
elected to public office. She has said that she believes Minnesota has some
of the worst racial disparities in the country. And that is why she says
she sought public office, to try to help change that.
Well, now, in the wake of George Floyd`s death, and the community grief and
outrage, Andrea Jenkins is calling on state and local officials to declare
racism a public health emergency.
Joining us now is Andrea Jenkins, Minneapolis City Council vice president.
Ms. Jenkins, thank you so much for being here, I know it is a whirlwind
right now in your city. Thank you for taking the time to be with us.
JENKINS: Thank you, Rachel. Happy to be here.
MADDOW: First, let me just ask you, we`ve seen you speak publicly over the
past couple of days, we`ve been watching from afar, watching the streets of
Minneapolis and Saint Paul, and worrying, frankly, can I just ask, how you
are, how you are holding up, and how you think your city is holding up now
after what`s been three very, very hard days?
JENKINS: Wow, Rachel, you know, with this opportunity to be on national
television, I do want to just take a moment to say, offer my condolences to
the Floyd family, the brothers and sisters, the friends, the girlfriend.
You know, words cannot express my deep sympathies.
I, like the rest of my community, we`re reeling. We`re in deep pain. We
feel that collectively, our lives don`t matter. The very people that we
paid to protect and serve our communities, it seems like, you know, I was
looking at the overview, as you led up to this story, all of the Philando
Castile, the Jamar Clark, the Justine Damond, and there are many more
police-involved murders that you didn`t name.
And so, this community has been just really overburdened by being
overpoliced, by being disinvested in, and really our cries and calls for
justice, have seemingly been ignored. Except in the case of a white woman
who was shot by a black police officer, and any police officer who commits
a crime should be held accountable and certainly Officer Noor (ph) was
being held accountable for his actions and the officers involved in this
latest police murder need to be held accountable as well.
I was devastated when I saw the non-press conference, because they didn`t
provide any press. There was no news. It simply was a lot of people talking
in a microphone.
And so, I know that my community is saying, where are the charges? Why
aren`t these officers in jail right now, until you get more evidence, Mr.
Freeman – you know, you saw the video, Rachel, as did the rest of the
America, and in fact, the whole world. I`ve been getting calls for media
requests from all over the world.
People really just are fed up with this sickness, this virus, that is
racism, that is literally killing us. And when I say “us” I mean all of us.
MADDOW: Let me ask you about what`s been happening the last three nights in
Minneapolis, and in Saint Paul, and we have seen solidarity demonstrations
in other cities around the country now, too, but it`s been so intense, in
Minneapolis, it looks like it`s going to be another very intense night.
You`ve been so eloquent in calling for people to be constructive and
peaceful and not destructive in their protests, but we`ve seen fires set,
we have seen violent confrontation, we`ve seen stuff destroyed, we`ve seen
stores looted, I guess the question is, whether you think that there is
receptiveness among the people who are out in the streets to channeling
this in a constructive way, to channel this in the kind of direction that
you`ve been calling for, or if you feel like this is still going to burn
for another night or more, just because the anger is there, it`s
unrelenting, and there is no channeling it?
JENKINS: So, you know, Rachel, I`ve been involved in these rallies,
protests, demonstrations, for the past three days. Ninety-eight percent of
the people have been peaceful, have been very succinct in their demands for
justice, to have these officers arrested, and so, I think the small number
of people who are creating the violence and the destruction, and none of
these, none of these protesters will be satisfied until we get a charge in
MADDOW: Andrea Jenkins, Minneapolis Council vice president, Ms. Jenkins, as
you say, I know you have been getting calls from all over the world right
now, in part because of your visibility, your leadership, and your
eloquence on these issues. I thank you for choosing to talk with us tonight
and the whole country is really pulling for Minneapolis tonight. Thank you.
JENKINS: Thank you so much, Rachel.
MADDOW: All right, we got much more ahead tonight. Stay with us.
MADDOW: Joining us now, I`m very pleased to say, is Keith Ellison. He`s
former Democratic congressman, former deputy chairman of the National
Democratic Party, he is now the duly elected attorney general of the great
state of Minnesota, a state that is in absolute turmoil right now with
these Twin Crises, a serious coronavirus pandemic that has driven record-
high hospitalizations, and today a record high death count and of course
the raging protest in the streets of Minnesota`s major cities in the
response to the death of George Floyd in police custody on Monday night.
General Ellison, thank you so much for making time to be with us tonight.
KEITH ELLISON, MINNESOTA ATTORNEY GENERAL: Thank you. Thanks for having us.
MADDOW: I – this is a little bit awkward, because we are in remote
cameras, we`re not in studio together, and there is a little bit of a
delay, but a little bit of breaking news that I want to present to you, and
I`m going to be seeing this at the same time you do, and it is a new video
that appears to show a different angle of the arrest of George Floyd, it`s
about a 15 second video, NBC News has obtained this, I`m going to be seeing
it for the first time here.
If you wouldn`t mind, Mr. Attorney general, watching it with us, and then
giving us your response, in terms of how you think this may affect either
the case or the community response. Is that OK with you?
ELLISON: Will do.
MADDOW: All right. Here we go. Let`s go ahead and roll that.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
GEORGE FLOYD: I can`t breathe, man. Please, please, let me stand (ph).
Please, I can`t breathe.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: NBC has just obtained this video, we believe that it is a second
angle from the video that you have, the whole country, the whole world has
now seen, of what appears to have led to George Floyd`s death. You can see
in that video one officer kneeling on Mr. Floyd, you can hear him saying he
The other officers that you can see there, it is sort of unclear to my view
if they are kneeling on Mr. Floyd as well or if they`re kneeling next to
Mr. Attorney General, I just have to ask your reaction to seeing that
second video, and what that may change about our understanding of the case,
ELLISON: Well, to me, it just confirms what we saw in the first video. It
clearly needs to be examined. It clearly needs to be investigated more
closely. But as I see that video, it looks like he is in a helpless
position, handcuffed. And without any ability to move, and he`s pleading
with the officers to bring some relief to him, now that he`s clearly within
their custody. So that`s what I see in that video.
MADDOW: Let me ask you, sir, to explain for our viewers the role of various
law enforcement agents, including yourself as the top law enforcement
official in the state of Minnesota, as the attorney general. We`ve got the
Justice Department today, the U.S. attorney for Minnesota saying that this
will be a top priority for the federal Justice Department, you have the
Hennepin county attorney pleading for patience, while everybody up to and
including the mayor of Minneapolis is basically demanding that the county
attorney bring charges against this officer.
As state attorney general, what is – what is your role here? And how do
you anticipate your role to change going forward?
ELLISON: Well, I represent every state agency in the state of Minnesota.
That includes the Commission of Public Safety which includes the Bureau of
Criminal Apprehension. So I`m their lawyer. I am the lawyer for the
constitutional officers, which includes the governor, and I am a statewide
public official, who has a bully pulpit, and is often called upon to offer
leadership to the state in various ways.
And so, all of those things I think are what I bring to bear. I will tell
the folks listening that in Minnesota, the jurisdiction, primary
jurisdiction for a crime is with the county attorney in the county in which
the crime is alleged to have occurred, which is why Mike Freeman is the
county attorney in this particular case, and the U.S. attorney is also
prioritizing this case, and allowing the FBI but they are taking a slightly
The state is looking at just a straight criminal investigation. The federal
government is looking at what they call a color of law investigation, which
is essentially a civil rights investigation. Did this case occur, did this
homicide occur because of some protected class status that Mr. Floyd is in?
Like did this happen because he was black?
Now, you know, this will mean, they will have to find evidence this was a
motivator, this case was driven by a fact like that. So, that`s the roles
everybody plays. The Minneapolis police are not investigating this case.
The Bureau of Criminal Apprehension is a state agency, which does
investigations and has now become the place where officer involved death,
deadly force encounters with police are investigated not by the local
jurisdiction but by the state. So, that the sort of how the landscape is
And, you know, we play an active role but we`re not directly the
prosecuting authority, but we stand ready to help if anyone asks and we are
glad to do so because we`re committed to justice in this matter. I may add
that myself and the Commission of Public Safety convened a task force on
preventing and stopping deadly force encounters with police.
We issued a report in February. That report called for training measures
and updates, a new standard of use of force, commitment to sanctity of
life, duty to intervene and a whole range of other things, as well. So,
call – convening the task force and calling for systemic change is another
thing that we do.
MADDOW: Mr. Attorney General, while we`re talking to you, we`re showing
live shots of people tearing down barriers and leaping up on barriers
around a precinct house in Minneapolis. We know the scenes in Minneapolis
and St. Paul over the last couple nights and what seems to be the still
really live brewing anger as we head into night fall tonight is an active
Let me ask you with state attorney general and the bully pulpit that you
have, and especially with your history as nationally known official and the
way that you have led on these issues, can you, with a full heart and
without holding anything back, can you tell the people of Minneapolis, out
there in the streets tonight, that the state agency that is going to be
doing the investigative work in this as an officer-involved shooting can be
trusted and can approach this in a way people should feel confidence in in
terms of justice being done?
ELLISON: Let me just say, people have been disappointed in the past and so
to tell them to believe in an institution that is disappointed them is a
lot to ask of people. What I can tell them is that we have driven and
pushed reform in the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. We have demanded they
change. We have seen the changes occur.
They can trust that I will be watching like a hawk to make sure that this
investigation is vigorous, is thorough, is expeditious and I believe that
the Commissioner of Public Safety John Harrington (ph) will do the same and
I believe the governor will do the same.
So asking people to believe when they have been let down a lot is a lot to
ask but what can we do other than do all that we can and that`s what we`re
going to do and I do believe because I believe in the people to hold me
accountable and others, I believe that we`re going to get justice in this
situation. I can`t have any other belief than that and I have to believe I
have reason to believe that, as well.
MADDOW: Keith Ellison, Minnesota state attorney general – sir, thank you
for joining us. This is a very, very intense time. Thanks for taking time
to be here with us.
ELLISON: Thank you, my pleasure. Thank you very much.
MADDOW: Let me ask – appreciate it.
Let me ask control room with the awkward delay. Am I allowed to go to the
reporter who I believe I just saw on camera as that was kicking off that
police precinct house? Is this still that live shot?
ALI VELSHI, MSNBC CORRESPONDENT: Yeah, Rachel, I`m here, you see two police
over there and one over there. This is the third precinct right now.
Protesters have just reached it. There is a barrier around it that`s come
down. They forced it down. They actually made their way into the police
You can see there they got inside and then police officers, you can see
they are tossing things at the police station. Three police officers
emerged with flash bang guns and fired into the crowd. This crowd moved
away very quickly.
Now people are slowly moving back and I have to tell you, Rachel, this was
completely calm until eight, nine minutes ago until you were talking to the
attorney general. Somebody got over the fence and started rattling it and
took it down. There was no fence here yesterday, by the way. This is brand-
new. This is where the four police officers were stationed and this is
where the heart of the protests were. You were looking at an earlier
protest was, this is where most of it is.
You can see people continuing to throw things at the building. There is no
police presence at all for most of the day without exception of one
incident a few hours earlier. We didn`t know there was police still in
there and when they breached the precinct, we saw the police come out
again. They are now rearming the flash bangs and getting ready to push the
crowd back if they come in closer.
But you can see that the third precinct continues to be – there we go.
That`s what`s going on there.
There are protesters here who are still saying despite the conversation you
had a little earlier with the mayor that they`ve seen the evidence and they
don`t believe there is any reason why the police have not been arrested
yet. You can see now this is more like what it was yesterday, tossing
things up there. You can see the police on top. They have now retreated and
the crowd is now responding to the fact the police are now out of sight.
But they are continuing to fire flash bangs. You can hear that. This is
become a very heated environment. There are bottles flying all over the
place. And there are still police.
You can see them on top there. They are throwing another flash bang down.
This is what was going on yesterday. We did not see this for most of today
but the barricade that had kept people from the police precinct has now
been breached. The police station has been breached. It does seem that the
protesters have come out of there now with a lot of anger right now on the
street between the police who are firing those flash bangs and the
protesters on this side.
They are also making note of the fact that they don`t want to see the
National Guard around here. You have not seen them in this area. I want to
ask Miguel to turn around.
This is AutoZone completely burned down. Several buildings down there
completely burned down. There is still a fire burning in the parking lot of
the target over here. A caret was set on fire. They threw the pressure
washer into the fire and he retrieved it.
This is the target the whole day. This is where the crowds have been and
speeches have been. This has been breached.
The third precinct with the police officers fired for their involvement in
the death of George Floyd were stationed here and they, the police are
trying to hold on to this. There`s no operations going on here. There are
no police cars anywhere around – there are no police cars anywhere but
there are obviously police in there.
We`ve seen three responding to this crowd right now. As you can see, the
crowd is angry, they are protesting but it has been peaceful here all day.
There has not been tension. This is the situation we got.
I don`t know what happens next. The perimeter has been breached. We have
police on the ground, Miguel. They are firing from the corner of the
building of the precinct where the perimeter has been breached. You can see
the flash bangs all around.
This is the first time all day that we have seen police on the ground. You
can see them now aiming the flash bangs. We have three police officers
clearly in sight right now and we do have protesters approaching them.
So despite the fact there are police there, the protesters are banking on
the fact that the police will not use live fire. You will remember last
night they used rubber bullets and tear gas. It`s windy today. There is no
tear gas in the air. There is tables set up around here with provisions
including people who think that milk helps offset that.
We have more flash bangs coming now, a fair amount of activity. The police
are firing in this direction. I want to ask Miguel to be careful. We have
four, five police at the corner pushing protesters back.
It appears the most logical thing to happen is the police will do what they
did last night. They will create and stand near each other and push the
crowds back and determine that the crowds are not going to continue to push
forward, however, I don`t know, we don`t have any tear gas, just smoke at
the moment. Last night it was tear gas which is what disbursed the crowds.
We got a canister that we got a canister down there. I think we`ll start to
see smoke coming this way. That`s the situation as we have it now. It seems
to have calmed down for the moment.
This is the third precinct. This is in south Minneapolis. It is about some
distance from where George Floyd was apprehended on Monday and where he
passed. But this has been the biggest center of attention right now.
Again, I`ll bring you up to speed. There are now a group of police officers
who have assembled at the corner of the third precinct on ground level. For
hours, we`ve not seen police here. A lot of tension as you can see, in the
MADDOW: Ali Velshi on the scene for us outside the third precinct in
Ali, we will stay with you and keep that shot live again this is south
Minneapolis. The third police precinct as Ali was saying this is the site
of a lot of peaceful protests over the course of the entire day. While we
were speaking live with the attorney general from the state, Keith Ellison,
we saw somebody get up on the fence and the police precinct and not being
used operationally, they have boarded up, boarded up over the windows.
We did see that perimeter get breached. We saw rocks and other things being
thrown at the building. We saw police merge and firing flash bang grenades,
which are basically fireworks, not exactly true. Not like they were firing
grenades designed to fragment and cause shrapnel and injure you. The flash
bangs grenades which are designed to be loud and something to make you
leave the area.
We saw live there those having diminishing returns as police continue to do
that from the roof. Now they are down on the ground floor, as well and that
situation seems to be devolving quickly in south Minneapolis. Again, this
is the third night of protest after the death of 46-year-old George Floyd,
father of two in police custody as police officer kneeled on his neck.
County attorney says he`s considering whether or not criminal charges
should be brought against the officers involved there but he pleaded for
patience while he makes those charging decisions, patience not in abundant
supply tonight in the streets of Minneapolis.
Thanks for being with us tonight. Our coverage continues.
It`s now time for “THE LAST WORD WITH LAWRENCE O`DONNELL”.
Good evening, Lawrence.
THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY
Copyright 2020 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the content.>
Copyright 2020 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are
protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced,
distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the
prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter
or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the