GOP slush fund TRANSCRIPT: 3/23/20, The Rachel Maddow Show
RACHEL MADDOW, MSNBC HOST: Good evening, Chris. Thank you, my friend. Much
And thanks to you at home for joining us this hour.
Here`s just one snapshot, one cross-section, one day in one U.S. state.
This is the front page of the “Minneapolis Star Tribune” right now.
Governor Walz in self quarantine. The governor of Minnesota is former
Democratic Congressman Tim Walz.
He is under quarantine as of tonight after coming into contact with someone
with COVID-19. It was believed to be a member of his security detail. The
governor says he is not showing any symptoms but he is going into
quarantine. That`s the governor.
Also, on the front page of “The Star Tribune” right now, a story about the
lieutenant governor of Minnesota. Her name is Peggy Flanagan, also on the
front page of that same paper right now, with the news that her brother has
just died from coronavirus. She described her brother as a tough as nails
And she says this, quote: If you feel fine, that`s great, but please
consider the possibility that you`re carrying the virus and don`t know it,
and then you walk past the next Ron, my big brother, in public. COVID-19
now has a personal connection to me. Please do all you can to prevent one
Also on that same front page, tonight, Minnesota`s confirmed case load as a
state, jumps from 169 known cases yesterday to 235 known cases today.
Also, on that same front page, the fact that the transit system in the Twin
Cities is cutting its service by, two days from now, by 40 percent.
And then there`s the news from Minnesota`s senior U.S. senator, Amy
Klobuchar. And again, the context here, in that state, the state`s governor
is now quarantined, the state`s lieutenant governor just announced that her
brother just died, and now, the state`s senior U.S. senator, Senator
Klobuchar, announces that her husband has coronavirus and he is
Quote: I have news that many Americans are facing right now. My husband
John has the coronavirus. We just got the test results at 7:00 a.m. this
She says, quote: John started to feel sick when I was in Minnesota and he
was in Washington, D.C. And like so many others who have had the disease,
he thought it was just a cold. Yet, he immediately quarantined himself just
in case and stopped going to his job teaching in Baltimore.
He kept having a temperature and a bad, bad cough, and when he started
coughing up blood, he got a test, and a chest X-ray, and they checked him
into a hospital in Virginia, because of a variety of things, including very
low oxygen levels, which haven`t really improved.
He now has pneumonia and is on oxygen but not a ventilator. While this
story is his and not mine, I wanted to let my colleagues and constituents
know that since John and I have been in different places for the past two
weeks, and I am outside the 14-day period for getting sick, my doctor has
advised me to not get a test. As everyone is aware, there are test
shortages for people who need them everywhere and I don`t qualify to get
one under any standard.
While I cannot see him and he is, of course, cut off from all visitors, our
daughter Abigail and I are constantly calling and texting and emailing. We
love him very much and pray for his recovery. He is exhausted and sick but
a very strong and resilient person.
I love my husband so very much, and not being able to be there at the
hospital by his side is one of the hardest things about this disease.
I hope he will be home soon. I know so many Americans are going through
this and so much worse right now. So I hope and pray for you, just as I
hope you will do for my husband. Meanwhile, I`m working in the Senate to
get help to the American people.
And that announcement today from U.S. senator and until recently Democratic
presidential candidate, Amy Klobuchar.
Joining us now, live from D.C., where she has stayed at work as the Senate
tries to pass a bill to mitigate the economic collapse caused by this virus
– Senator Klobuchar, thank you so much for making time to be here tonight.
SEN. AMY KLOBUCHAR (D-MN): Well, thank you, Rachel. And thank you for
mentioning my good friend Peggy Flanagan whose brother so tragically died.
And I think one of the things about this happening to me and to so many
others, is it`s going to happen to every family, it`s going to happen to
everyone, whether it is a friend or your grandpa, and one of the things you
find out when this happens, which Peggy knows too, is you can`t go and
visit your loved one.
I would love to be at my husband`s side right now. But instead, I`m with
you, which is fine, on this show. But it is so hard, because you want to
talk to the doctor, and be there. You want to see what the oxygen levels
are, you want to bring flowers, and you can`t do any of that.
And that`s going to happen to everyone, because visiting someone in the
hospital makes it so much worse, because you can pick up the disease, or
spread it to other people.
And if my husband hadn`t did what he did, he literally went into the
apartment, and never left, except to get groceries, and was very careful, I
think a lot of other people would have gotten sick from him. And I think
that`s one thing you learn from people that get sick, but it`s also people
that just have to stay in their houses, and listen to the experts right
now. I can`t tell you how important that is.
MADDOW: You said in your statement that he has had low oxygen levels and
that he`s in the hospital, he`s getting oxygen. Can you give us any update
on his condition and what – what you are, at least, what his doctors are
able to say about what they expect for his prognosis?
KLOBUCHAR: Well, one of the things he had, which is so common, is he had
over 100 degree temperature, for ten days, and it was really only when he
coughed up the blood that he went to get the test, because we knew how hard
it was to get the test and then it took, you know, five and a half days,
like so many people have experienced, to get the results. And so, that was
this morning, and that`s when we knew for sure, but all weekend, we thought
that it was probably it.
And so right now, he`s still at that low oxygen level, he is still on
oxygen. But we`re just so glad that he hasn`t gotten to the point of
needing a ventilator, and so, they`re waiting to see what happens because
one of the strange things with this disease is it can just suddenly
And, of course, he`s saying, I got to go teach my class remotely. And I`m
like no. And so, at some point, I mean, the hope is he will probably come
home with oxygen, but the minute he can come home, he will.
So, you know, we don`t know. These things have taken a turn for the worse,
like Peggy`s brother, who had cancer, and so that was part of what went on
there, but there is a lot of other people that suddenly, for no reason, it
takes a turn.
So I am just hoping and praying for him like I am for so many people across
the country. Like I said, many people have had worse or will have worse.
And it`s made me, as I was, obsessively focused on getting these tests out
to people, getting them in much more available, making them quicker, so
health care workers know, getting the equipment to healthcare workers,
everything would make a difference for people right now.
And that`s why I`m here and I`m so proud of our Democratic Caucus, hanging
together, from the most progressive people in our caucus, to the more
moderate conservatives, everyone hung together, everyone said no, everyone
said we`ve got to do better for the hospitals.
And Senator Schumer and Senator Durbin and Murray and so many others, did
such a great job on this. They`ve been negotiating through the night, as
well as so – it was such a team effort, and we are working on, of course,
unemployment insurance, and small businesses. And I keep pushing to get
those ballots ready, so we can have our mail-in ballots.
There`s just been so much good work going on right now, and the American
people should not settle for what they`ve had to date, which is not enough
tests, not enough equipment. And that`s why I`m here tonight, and so many
of my colleagues are working around the clock.
MADDOW: There has been this – this fight in the Senate, as you`re
describing, all Democrats, standing together, and saying what Senator
McConnell is offering is not the right response, it`s not enough, it
doesn`t meet the right priority, not the right way to deal with this. It
certainly feels like a clash between two immovable sides, but there`s also
this urgency to get some relief passed.
KLOBUCHAR: Yes, I think that actually there have been some really positive
developments in the last few hours, because of all of this work that`s
going on. I know I`ve talked to at least ten of my Republican colleagues
today, and I know that those that are in the committees, like I can`t even
– Senator Warner, and Senator Cardin, Senator Shaheen, that are just
working so hard, that are negotiating all of this right now. I think that`s
key (ph) – Senator Leahy, of course, with Appropriations.
There`s just been a lot of work going on that`s positive that I still think
that there is a good chance we`re going to get an agreement. And then, of
course, Speaker Pelosi has her bill that has a lot of things in it that is
difficult to get through the Republican Senate, but would make the bill so
So I just cannot stress enough for your viewers how hard people are working
so that we have a bill that puts people first, and it`s going to get that
equipment out, and make us so much better prepared when this next group of
patients are going to be coming in, and we know that they`re coming in.
MADDOW: Senator, let me just also ask you about your workplace right now.
By last – my last count, I think that five members of the Senate are now
quarantined. Senator Rand Paul has tested positive. While he was awaiting
his test results, he was coming into work every day, reportedly using
facilities like the Senate gym.
As a member of the government, as a senior member of the government, in the
branch that you`re in, are you worried about a situation in which a single
– a significant number of people who are involved in the government are
essentially out of commission at the same time, we`re already in an awkward
situation in the Senate, where there`s a good number of senators who can`t
come in to cast votes?
KLOBUCHAR: Oh, yes, and that`s why I`m a proponent for remote voting. That
is something that a number – Rob Portman called me about it today, he`s
been working on it, Senator Durbin and others. And I`m ranking on the Rules
Committee, and having seen these senators now either quarantined, off and
on, off and on, we`re going to have to do more work, Rachel.
I don`t think we`re going to get everything we want on the mail-in ballots,
and I think we could because we have Democrats and Republican secretaries
of states that actually want to have a democracy, an election where people
can vote in the fall. And so, there`s a number of things that we`re pushing
for right now and there`s some things we`re going to be doing in the next
month, and people are going to have to vote.
And so, one of the ways you can do this, and I looked at this, I believe
it`s legal under the Constitution, as long as we change the rules of the
chamber, on a very emergency basis, to allow for some remote voting, and
especially when it pertains to these emergency measures.
So that`s one of the things we`re pushing for. The staffs are the ones that
are on the front line, and I think again, I just keep going back to the
grocery store workers, and the doctors and nurses, and the janitors, and
the people who are taking care of their neighbors, and leaving groceries on
the front porch. We`re going to be tested as a country, like we`ve never
been tested before.
And the way you have to do this is to step back, and be grateful, and be
generous in spirit. When all these things are going wrong, that there are
people that are going to work every single day, including staff members, in
the Congress, but including those police officers at the front door of this
place, including – that right now, all of these health care workers, like
the ones treating my husband that I have never gotten to thank because I`ve
never gotten to meet them, because I can`t go there. They are doing this
incredible job, and putting themselves at risk, and the least they deserve
is the best equipment that money can buy.
MADDOW: Senator Amy Klobuchar, Democrat of Minnesota, we wish, of course,
John an absolutely swift and complete recovery.
KLOBUCHAR: Yes (ph)
MADDOW: We look forward to him being immune from this disease after his
recovery, so he can be one of the super heroes who`s going to help us on
the other side of this curve.
MADDOW: Thank you for making time for us –
MADDOW: – Senator.
KLOBUCHAR: That`s what I keep telling him to make him feel better. That is
a good point. So, thank you.
KLOBUCHAR: Thank you, Rachel.
MADDOW: Well, tell him that THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW is with you on that.
Thank you, Senator.
KLOBUCHAR: OK, excellent.
MADDOW: We`ve got a lot of news to get to tonight. Well, first, let me
give you what we think may amount to a little bit of good news. Honestly,
good news is overstating it a little bit. But it is potentially the light
at the end of someone else`s tunnel. At least it`s reason to hope.
Let me tell you about this. For a couple of weeks now, as Italy became the
largest epicenter of the pandemic, as Italy surpassed China in terms of its
death toll, as northern Italian hospitals have become overrun by seriously-
ill coronavirus patients, as it has just been absolutely terrible in Italy,
we have repeatedly been warned in this country, by people in a position to
know, that the shape and the scale of the Italian epidemic is where the
United States is heading.
That overall of course is terrible news, because Italy is in terrible
shape. But the reason to hope, that`s coming out of Italy right now, is
that Italy may, may, I repeat may, be starting to turn the corner. China
and South Korea had the two first worst epidemics as you know, and their
graphs went straight down and then came down, they had the two first worst
epidemics and they each turned the corner against them and they have
additional challenges and things aren`t over, but those numbers came down.
In Italy, things are still terrible. And their death toll is higher now
than China or South Korea ever got. But after living with weeks of a
national stay at home order, Italy may have finally come to that kind of
inflection point that both China and South Korea hit, where things started
to turn in a better direction.
Last week, we reported here on the show that the number of new infections,
newly-reported cases in Italy, had started to show a smaller rate of
growth. Still terrible. Still getting lots of new infections. But the rate
of growth in new cases had started to shrink.
As of today, the rate of increase in new coronavirus cases in Italy is down
in the single digits for the first time. They still have 13.5 percent
double digit growth, as of Saturday, but as of today, it is down to just
over 8 percent. It`s the first time they have had single digit growth in
new cases since things got terrible, right?
It`s still growing. Still terrible. But those numbers are finally starting
to head in the right direction in terms of newly-discovered cases.
And now, it`s the same kind of news on deaths in Italy. We have been
watching in horror over the past week, as the death toll rose and rose all
week long, last week, as Italy started to see one-day death numbers that
were higher than anything China reported in any sustainable way, at the
worst of the Chinese epidemic.
Well, now, the number of daily deaths in Italy is still abominably,
unimaginably, but the daily death numbers in Italy have finally started to
decline. We reported last week that Italy had climbed up over 300 deaths a
day, over 400 deaths a day. On Saturday, Italy hits 793 deaths per day. On
Sunday, it was not 793, it was 651. Today, they announced it was 608.
And that`s still very bad. That`s still the worst on earth. But in the
place that has it the worst on earth right now, it is starting to very
slowly get better. The numbers are starting to go in the right direction.
And why is that? Well, as I mentioned, and as you know, Italy has a
national stay at home order. Italy put in place a national stay at home
order and travel restrictions March 9th. That`s only two weeks ago. Just
like a decade ago, doesn`t it?
Two weeks ago they put that order in place and the experts said at the time
that the Italian authorities were expecting that it would take two weeks to
start to show any beneficial effect of that national stay at home order in
terms of just starting to slow it, starting to tame that raging out of
control epidemic. Well, it is two weeks ago today, since they put in place
that national order, and now, as of today, their curves in terms of new
case, the curves, in terms of deaths, are finally starting to flatten just
a little tiny bit.
And that is, you know, thousands of deaths down the road. But maybe for
them, the inflection point is within site. Maybe the light at the end of
the tunnel is at least imaginable.
We, on the other hand, have a raging out of control epidemic in this
country, and we even now, even with those kinds of examples, around the
world, see what China did to fix it, see what South Korea did to fix it,
see what Italy didn`t do in time to avoid the calamity they are in now,
seeing what their two-week national effort has finally started to yield, in
terms of benefits, we in this country, with our raging out of control
epidemic, are only barely starting to take the measures that will offer us
any hope of slowing it down.
I mean, California was first, with a statewide stay at home order. Then
Illinois and New York joined them. And now, finally, in hither and yon,
when they get around to it, other states are starting to follow. Over the
past few days, on Saturday, New Jersey joined the stay at home order as
well. On Sunday, it was Delaware, and also Louisiana, and also Ohio.
Today, it was Michigan, and West Virginia, and Wisconsin, and
Massachusetts, and Indiana, and Connecticut goes into effect today.
Missouri finally announced school closures. But still, there`s no stay at
home order in Missouri.
Idaho, announced 27 new confirmed cases today, but the governor of Idaho
has no interest in say banning gatherings of any size, he`s apparently fine
leaving restaurants and bars and whatever other businesses to do whatever
they want and that leaves the state of Idaho`s cities and towns to invent
it themselves, figure it out themselves, put in place their own measures if
they want to if they can figure it out, but hey, rush, no worry, statewide,
the governor thinks everything will be fine, right?
Here`s the front page of the “Idaho Statesman” right now. For every ICU bed
in Idaho, experts predict we will have one to 14 patients who need it. You
may be about to outstrip your ICU beds by a factor of 14. You know what
kind of condition people are in when they need an ICU bed? And they`re not
going to be able to get them by a factor of up to 14?
Yes, no rush, Governor. No rush. It will probably work out OK. Even if you
don`t do anything statewide to slow the spread in your state, sure,
probably, why not risk, it see what happens.
In Brazil, they are now using their gigantic Brazilian soccer stadiums as
field locations for new coronavirus hospitals. In Austria, this weekend,
volunteers and firefighters converted a convention center in Vienna, to an
880-bed hospital, literally over the course of one weekend, they did that.
In Spain, which has the second worst outbreak in Europe, after Italy,
officials announced today that an ice rink in Madrid will be converted into
a huge new morgue, because existing morgue facilities cannot keep up with
the hundreds of deaths per day, with increasing numbers expected every day
ahead, because Spain has not yet hit an inflection point, and started to
turn this thing back, or slow it at all.
Here at home, in Maryland today, the governor of Maryland, Larry Hogan,
announced that the Baltimore convention center will be converted into a
large field hospital. The Hilton Hotel in downtown Baltimore`s inner harbor
will also be converted into a hospital overflow care center.
In New York, which is now becoming a world capital of coronavirus impact,
it`s starting to feel like America has this one president in Washington,
but a whole different president for the coronavirus crisis who is the guy
in charge of New York, who President Trump and Washington literally said
this weekend, that GM and Ford are making ventilators, he said, quote,
right now, when that is absolutely not happening.
I mean, President Trump has continued, inexplicably hyping supposed miracle
cures for the virus, right? We`ve got a president of the United States, who
is operating in Washington, the president of the coronavirus response still
does appear to be the guy who is in charge in New York, where New York, as
a state, is forging ahead into the darkest days of this crisis.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
GOV. ANDREW CUOMO (D), NEW YORK: We are today issuing an emergency order
that says to all hospitals, you must increase your capacity by 50 percent.
You must. Mandatory directive from the state.
Find more beds. Use more rooms. You must increase your capacity 50 percent.
We would ask you to try to increase your capacity 100 percent. OK? So we
now have 53,000 beds. We need 110,000 beds.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: Today, they announced that the Javits Center, the giant convention
center in Manhattan, they are going to put four 250-person FEMA hospitals
inside it. That`s 1,000 beds. They think it will be done within a week.
The Army Corps of Engineers is reportedly going to filled out another
thousand bed capacity at that same site. So 2,000 beds at the Javits
Center, plus New York is planning on three other sites where they will put
250-bed hospitals at two state college sites, in Old Westbury and Stony
Brook and another at the convention center in Westchester County.
They are also scouting nursing homes and other health care sites that the
state can temporarily take over to basically commandeer them and make them
into new hospital bed space, new overflow bed space, as New York hospitals,
particularly New York City hospitals fill up.
In New York, last week, they asked recently retired doctors and nurses to
come back into service and help. Thirty thousand doctors and nurses signed
up and said they would. Imagine seeing something like that going on inside
your country, seeing New York hospitals filling up lightning fast. And
doctors and nurses, by the tens of thousands, answering the call, coming
out of retirement, to relieve the doctors and nurses who are themselves
going to get sick and themselves die in some numbers, because we don`t have
the resources to protect them, as the patient numbers surge out of control.
Imagine being in a position of authority anywhere in this country, looking
across this country, no matter how far away you are, looking across this
country, to the biggest city in this country, the first worst-hit city in
this country, knowing that the virus is already in all 50 states, imagine
being in a position of authority, looking at the first worst-hit city in
our country, hearing about the nurses already reusing the same protective
masks for days at a time, already.
Imagine being like the governor of Idaho, Brad Little, looking at that and
deciding, eh, no big deal, I`m sure that won`t happen us to, why would I
tell people to stay home in Idaho, we don`t need any state-wide order, I`m
sure we will be fine. And if we won`t be fine, I`ll leave it to the mayors
and stuff to figure it out if they want to do something, but statewide, I`m
going to do nothing. Imagine that.
Donald McNeil, the veteran science correspondent at “The New York Times”
has just published a gigantic and chilling 5,000-word piece about what the
expert international consensus now is, what we have now learned, about what
needs to happen to shut down the epidemic and save millions of lives. I
will tell you right now, it is not what we are doing, with this patchwork
of responses, and non-responses, where maybe some states try to tackle it
and some others don`t.
Donald McNeil joins us live next. Stay with us.
MADDOW: Donald McNeil is the veteran science and health reporter at “The
New York Times”. We`ve had him several times since the start of our
basically full-time reporting on the pandemic. McNeil has been pioneering
reporting on the coronavirus pandemic since its inception and the most
recent article is on the front page of today`s “New York Times,” above the
fold and it will be seen as a landmark piece of journalism in the early
U.S. response to this crisis. It`s called: Halting virus will require harsh
steps, experts say, near total cooperation from public is key to isolating
clusters of infections.
In this piece, McNeil writes that stopping the virus, quote, takes
intelligent, rapidly adaptive work by health officials, and near-total
cooperation from the populace. Containment becomes realistic only when
Americans realize that working together is the only way to protect
themselves and their loved ones.
Donald McNeil joins us now live.
Sir, thank you very much for your time. I really appreciate you being here.
DONALD MCNEIL, SCIENCE AND HEALTH REPORTER, THE NEW YORK TIMES: Thank you.
MADDOW: I mentioned a few states in the introduction tonight that have
recently added state-wide stay at home orders, singled out a few states
that haven`t. I should also mention that Oregon`s new stay at home order
goes into effect today. Hawaii just announced one that goes into effect on
Wednesday. We are seeing the sort of patch work quilt of these stay at home
Are those types of orders in keeping with what international experts told
you should be done?
MCNEIL: Yes, as long as they`re serious orders and they are seriously paid
attention to by the populace. There`s all sorts of wiggle room and lots of
orders. People are still gathering out and playing in the park, basketball
and stuff, and transfer the virus, people are still, you know, having play
dates, several kids together.
So it all depends on how people cooperate, if people recognize that they
could be passing the virus or picking up the virus in any human
MADDOW: In terms of the American capacity to do what needs to be done,
some of the things that you outlined in this new reporting feel doable if
not politically difficult. For example, the first thing you suggested is
the scientists need to be heard, that the people who are doing the day to
day explaining of what`s going on, what the dynamics are of the epidemic
right now, what needs to be done to stop it and why, should be scientists
and not politicians, you wrote, in the same way that General Schwarzkopf
was the person explaining what is going on in the Gulf War to the American
people. That seems at least theoretically doable.
But some of the other things that you talk about, I sort of have been
reading between the lines but it seems that you are not sure America will
ever get it together to do some of the more extreme forms of isolation and
MCNEIL: We are not nearly as together as the Italians right now who are
not famous for cooperation with authority at any time. You know, in
Tennessee, people are still insisting on going, the right to go to bars. In
England, you know, the minute they heard that the bars were going to close
down, the bars were flooded for last call.
You know, no. And this is just, this is just the beginning. This is just an
attempt to freeze everything in place. Then the real work begins.
And the real work includes first of all, you`ve got to get people who are
infected out of their homes, so that they don`t infect their family
members. And that means they`re going to have to go, even if they have mild
cases, even if they have almost no symptoms, they`re going to have to go
some blase where they can get over it together, and so that the ones who
crash, which is a big phenomena the second week, people who seem to be
doing fine and some will crash and need to be on oxygen, you don`t want to
be having to call 911 at that point because there may be no ambulance for
You would be much better off in something like the Javits Center where
there is a nurse keeping an eye on everybody in the room who has a number
of oxygen tanks by the wall so when you need oxygen somebody can get it to
you instantly. And plus we need to find the fevers. Plus, we need to test
literally millions of people because the first thing you get the test, it
means nothing. And a negative test yields no information. You sometimes, it
takes three or four days, even after you have symptoms, for a test to turn
So there is a lot of, a lot had more to do, even, a lot more to do even
after we go into a lockdown. And the president is talking about, after 15
days, this may likely be over. And that`s a disastrous way to look at it.
MADDOW: In terms of finding the fevers, I was interested to see that Dr.
Fauci did an interview with “Science Magazine” in which the interviewer
asked him, you know, listen in, China, one of the things they do, they
point an infrared thermometer at your forehead before they allow you in the
grocery store, before they allow you on the bus to check to see if you`ve
got a fever. Is that something that we should be doing?
And Dr. Fauci responded positively to that and said I will bring this up in
the task force meetings, logistically, I don`t know if we can do it, but we
– there is a good case to be made for doing that. To hear him talk about a
measure like that positively is of interest on its own terms but, of
course, it raises the questions of what we would do with people who had
What you`ve described is this sort of temporary hospitals where people who
have mild or moderate illness, have to leave their families, people who
have fevers and get diagnosed, even just mild cases, need to be isolated
outside of their home. That would be – that would be the next logistical
next you`d need in order for it to make sense to widely screen people for
MCNEIL: Yes. Look, this is tough. You have to see this as an open carry
issue. Is it safe to walk into a grocery store while openly carrying a
fever? You`re in endangering the other people in the store.
You know, you yourself may not even recognize that you`re sick and
The fever doesn`t mean you`re took (ph) to the isolation. The fever means,
in China, that you`re taken for a test to see what the cause of your fever
is, you know? They try to pull out flu and they try to pull out the
possibility of it being pneumonia, and see, aha, OK, if you have
coronavirus, we`re going to put you in isolation.
It`s – for your own protection. Not every case is mild. It`s a misnomer to
believe. You probably seen the TV today. I mean, I had an email from a
family of a 25-year-old guy, very athletic young man, he is in induced coma
and on a ventilator now, and he can`t get Gilead`s remdesivir drug and
there is a 12-year-old girl in Georgia who is now, you know, may or may not
This notion that it is all – this notion that it is all only going to kill
grandma, as if that were OK, has – has got to stop.
MADDOW: Do you think that the problems that we`ve seen –I don`t want you
to, I don`t ask you to do any political discussion that you don`t want to
do – but because we have had such a patch work response of mistakes,
because there have been problems, with the president`s communication,
around this issue, where he has said things that aren`t true, that he has
wild goose chased himself and happy talked this thing to the point that it
is unrecognizable compared to the ground truth, do you think we should be
hoping for federal nationwide orders, for their federal government, in
other words, to get its act together or should we be just hoping for
individual states to develop best cases that well meaning governors in
other states can then copy?
MCNEIL: I don`t hold out much hope for federal orders, because the
president is seeming to have a hard time believing in this germ. In this –
I mean, when he`s talking about it, 15, you know, 15 days, the doors are
open, it`s like, you know, having a lead-lined room next to the Chernobyl
power plant and you fling open the doors and say, hey, the flowers are
still sprouting out there, it`s a sunny day, I think it`s OK to go out.
It`s not OK to go out. You know, there are things that you haven`t seen yet
because so many people are getting infected but they`re not going to be
hospitalized for, on average, another 10 days after they show symptoms,
it`s only going to be forced home in the same way that AIDS was forced home
to Ronald Reagan after four years of not mentioning it by the death of his
friend Rock Hudson.
Something`s going to have to wake the president up to the realization that
this is a very serious danger, including to him, and his family, and being
cavalier about it, in order to save your 401(k) is probably a short-term
good with really bad long-term consequences.
MADDOW: Donald McNeil, reporter at “The New York Times,” who again has
published what will be seen as a definitive, at least landmark piece of
journalism, in terms of rounding up international expert opinion on what to
do here. Thank you for being with us tonight, Don. I appreciate it.
MCNEIL: Thank you for inviting me.
MADDOW: All right. We`ve got – we`ve got much more ahead tonight,
including some of the doctors who are trying to raise the alarm in trying
to create some constructive pathways to get doctors and nurses more
protective gear, so that they can stay in the fight.
Let`s lots still to get to tonight. Stay with us.
MADDOW: We know we have a ventilator shortage in this country. As the
number of coronavirus cases skyrockets, as the number of people
hospitalized starts to rise steeply, as the number of people hospitalized
and needing intensive care also starts to rise steeply, we have a shortage
of ventilators in this country.
But do we even know where the ventilators are that we do have? And where
they are most needed? And where they might be repurposed to maximize the
number of human lives saved?
President Trump seems to believe that Ford and GM right now are producing
new ventilators. He said as much this weekend. Ford and GM right now are
not producing new ventilators.
But if U.S. manufacturing of these things does start to surge, do we know
at that point how those new machines would get where they are most needed?
One doctor at Mass General in Boston writes this in “The New York Times.”
Where should these ventilators be delivered? Which hospitals need them
most? How can we build a nimble logistics operation that can rapidly deploy
these machines the moment that a shortage appears imminent? The truth is we
have no idea.
We are currently taking an every hospital system for themselves approach.
Big tech needs to rapidly build and scale a cloud-based national ventilator
surveillance platform which will track hospital ICU capacity and ventilator
supply across the nation in real time. Such a platform which Silicon Valley
could build and FEMA could utilize would allow hops nationwide to report
the hospital bed status and their ventilator supply daily in an
unprecedented data sharing initiative.
That`s a proposal from Dr. Daniel Horn who is helping lead the pandemic
response effort at Mass General in Boston. A national ventilator
surveillance system, basically.
I mean if we`re honest, in addition to doing something like that for
ventilators, which seems like a great idea, we could really use a similar
tracking and delivery and resupply system for the life-saving personal
protective equipment that health workers are already running out of.
Well, there are some people who are now trying to do that themselves, on
their own time. But trying to create and run a private sourcing and
delivery system on a national scale for the kinds of equipment that health
care workers need to keep them uninfected and alive in this pandemic. The
group is called Project N95, the national COVID-19 medical equipment
And it`s part of a digital tech-driven response to the coronavirus
pandemic, launched by three people who used to work for the White House
chief technology officer. That`s a position that was created during the
So do you work in a facility where you need N95 masks or surgical masks? Or
isolation gowns? Even ventilators? Tell Project N95 where you are, and what
On the other side of the supply and demand chain, do you have any of those
things? Are you making any of those things? Do you expect that you will be
able to procure or make any of those things? Well, send information to this
clearinghouse, about what you have, and where it is.
Are you a local government looking for bulk orders to distribute across
various health care facilities? Project N95 says they will work on
connecting you with suppliers.
And it remains to be seen how successful a project like this will be.
Redistributing resources is really important, at a time of scarcity, but
the original sin here is scarcity, the original sin here is the question of
whether there is enough, even if you distribute it with perfect efficiency.
But hey, it`s an effort. We`re trying. Folks are using the skills they have
to try to fill – and fill the gigantic void that has been left by the
federal government, who did no planning for this, and who squandered weeks
of advanced notice, as to what was coming. But in terms of what it`s like
living with this situation, as it is right now, as the numbers of
coronavirus patients start to rise, in emergency rooms, and intensive care
units, the doctors who are on the front lines in hospitals, as they are
starting to become inundated with this wave of coronavirus patients, the
doctors and the nurses, are the ground truth of this.
Regardless of what ideas are cooking or percolating or what people are
planning, there are health care providers right now who are living with
this right now, who are very clear on exactly what it is that they need.
MADDOW: Joining us now is Dr. Megan Ranney. She`s an emergency physician
at Rhode Island hospital, which is affiliated with Brown University. Along
with other medical professionals, Dr. Ranney founded the website
#getusppe.org, as an outline hub to try to match those with access to masks
and other basic protective equipment with the folks who need it most, our
front line doctors and nurses.
Dr. Ranney, thank you so much for taking time to join us tonight.
DR. MEGAN RANNEY, EMERGENCY PHYSICIAN: It`s my honor, Rachel. Thank you.
MADDOW: What`s the situation right now at Rhode Island hospital and among
you and your colleagues as you`re starting to see cases?
RANNEY: So I`m lucky to be in a state and hospital system that have been
really proactive about this pandemic. We saw it coming months ago and have
been working to try and conserve supplies, to use – set up space, to do
everything we can to make sure that we`re adequately prepared.
But the number of cases is rising in our state and as you know, we`re not
actively testing the patients who come through the doors of the emergency
department. And although doctors and nurses and housekeeping staff have
trained for this and are 100 percent committed, we`ve never faced a
pandemic of this nature before, much less without adequate protective
I mean, the CDC guidelines are telling us to reuse protective equipment
that normally would be completely disposable. We are changing our normal
protocols in order to try and conserve supplies. The mood across the nation
right now in emergency departments is one of fear.
MADDOW: In terms of what we can do as a country, what we can do as
citizens to try to lessen the burden on you as an emergency room physician
and for other front line providers who are really going to be taking the
brunt of this, obviously, the idea of these social distancing measures is
to try and slow down the number of new cases that turned up in the hospital
and need urgent care.
At the president`s press conference today he said, our country wasn`t built
to be shut down, he said, normal life will return soon. He seems to be
suggesting that the social distancing measures we`re taking should be
relieved sometime soon. I have to ask how that landed with you.
RANNEY: That landed pretty poorly. I can`t emphasize enough how important
social distancing is right now. So when you stay apart from people, you
prevent the transmission of the virus. We know from Italy that it is
starting to work. There is preliminary data out of San Francisco under
Governor Gavin Newsom`s direction that they`re starting to see a decrease
in the number of new cases because they put social distancing in place
We know it takes about two weeks for the virus to show up. So, maintaining
that distance now is absolutely critical. And here`s the thing, it matters
not just because I don`t want people to be infected by COVID-19, but it
also matters because if my emergency department is full of critically ill
patients with COVID-19, I`m not going to have the resources to take care of
appendicitis or a car crash or a heart attack.
Now, again, my hospital system is preparing for these eventualities. But
nationwide, we`re going to be overwhelmed and we`re not going to be able to
take care of the everyday emergencies that folks have whether or not
there`s a pandemic out there. So social distancing is just critical. Now is
not the time to say that we`re done with it.
MADDOW: Dr. Megan Ranney, an emergency physician at Rhode Island Hospital,
thank you so much for your work and thanks for taking time to talk with us.
Getusppe.org is a clarion call to wake people up as to what you guys are
facing and what you need. Thanks for doing that work.
RANNEY: Thank you, Rachel. Appreciate it.
MADDOW: All right. We`ll be right back. Stay with us.
MADDOW: I have just the thing for you. How about a best new thing in the
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
MO WILLEMS, AUTHOR: Today is Monday, March 23rd. It`s our second week of
Mo Lunch Doodles –
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MADDOW: That is children`s book author Mo Willems who gave the world
Elephant and Piggie and Knuffle Bunny and the Pigeon who definitely should
not be allowed to drive the bus. And with the help of the Kennedy Center,
Mo Willems is also as of now America`s ad hoc at home art teacher.
Quote: With millions of learners attempting to grow and educate themselves
and new circumstances, I`ve decided to invite everyone into my studio once
a day for the next few weeks. You might be isolated but you`re not alone.
You are an art maker. Let`s make some together.
You might be isolated but you are not alone. It`s basically a doodling
master class, which is fantastic. It`s called Lunch Doodles. It`s free
online. So far, it`s kind of a hit with tons and tons and tons of kids
tuning in and making some pretty fine artwork including, full disclosure
here, some of our own.
These are the littlest RACHEL MADDOW SHOW producers with their doodles that
they have done with lunch doodles. We are very proud. We`re all trying to
do good work, to be creative, to try to find ways to do the most we can to
help our country and be good citizens and good members of our families and
communities. This is the kind of thing that helps.
Be creative. Be creatively engaged. Stay engaged. Like the doodle says, we
are all connected.
And that is the best new thing in the world. That`s going to do it for us.
We will see you again, same bat time, same bat channel tomorrow.
Now, it`s time for “THE LAST WORD WITH LAWRENCE O`DONNELL”.
Good evening, Lawrence.
THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY
Copyright 2020 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the content.>
Copyright 2020 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are
protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced,
distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the
prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter
or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the