President Trump holds first re-election rally. TRANSCRIPT: 6/18/19, Hardball w/ Chris Matthews.

Guests:
Jonathan Sykes, Danielle Moodie-Mills, Tim O`Brien, Charlie Sykes, Amy Klobuchar
Transcript:

ARI MELBER, MSNBC HOST:  And that does it for me.  We`ll have coverage of

that and a lot of more tomorrow at 6:00 P.M. Eastern.  But right now, it`s

“HARDBALL” with Chris Matthews is up next.

 

CHRIS MATTHEWS, MSNBC HOST:  The day he doubles down.  Let`s play HARDBALL.

 

Good evening.  I`m Chris Matthews up in New York back from our special town

hall event in Dayton, Ohio, The Deciders.  We learned a lot about how

democrats and republicans view President Trump.  It was a fascinating

evening last night and we`re going to have more on that coming up later in

the hour.

 

First tonight, President Donald Trump is set to take the stage in the next

hour in Orlando, there`s that crowd, where he`ll formally launch his bid

for re-election in 2020.  Hyping the event this morning, Trump compared

himself to a rock star, Tweeting, look what is going on in Orlando Florida

right now.  People have never seen anything like it unless you play a

guitar, going to be wild.

 

Well, there is no question that Trump is in a uniquely different position

today than he was four years ago when he made his – there it is, his

descent down that elevator at Trump Tower.  As The New York Times puts it

today in the paper, four years ago, Trump was seen as a sideshow.  Now, he

is the show.  He has firmly seized control of his party in a way that was

almost unimaginable in 2016.  That is for sure.  The Republican Party is

the Trump party.

 

Yet despite the power of incumbency, The New York Times notes that Trump is

the only president in the history of polling who has never once, not for a

single day, earned the support of a majority of Americans surveyed by

Gallup.  That`s important.

 

In advance of his announcement tonight, Trump is hitting the same themes

that accompanied his 2016 campaign.  Early today, he threatened to deport

millions of immigrants who had entered the country illegally in a major

crackdown starting next week.

 

Trump may be trying to distract, of course, from the recent leak of

internal campaign polling data from March, which showed his underperforming

in a dozen states against former Vice President Joe Biden, (INAUDIBLE) that

news out.  The details from that poll, which were obtained by NBC News,

showed Trump losing by double digits in Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania

and Florida, where Trump is tonight.  The Trump campaign says that polling

data is old, but a new Quinnipiac poll out just today shows Biden leading

Trump in Florida by nine points.

 

I`m joined right now by Danielle Moodie-Mills, SiriusXM Host, Tim O`Brien

is Executive Editor of Bloomberg Opinion, Jonathan Swan is a National

Political Reporter for Axios and Charlie Sykes is Editor-in-Chief of the

bulwark.  So that Bulwark always scares me.

 

Well, let`s start with Jonathan.  First question, but everybody gets the

same question.  How is Trump look like as a re-election candidate?  Big

question.  Let`s give me a big answer.  How does it look?

 

JONATHAN SWAN, NATIONAL POLITICAL REPORTER, AXIOS:  He looks bad right now. 

But it`s early.  And at this point in the last cycle, we were still

fantasizing by Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio and Scott Walker.  So he looks bad. 

Their internal polls have Biden taking a lot of the voters who delivered

Trump the presidency in 2016 all throughout the rust belt.  Trump can deny

those figures, but that`s the truth.  They`re internal figures.  But I

think we`re very, very foolish to make grand proclamations at this stage

about Trump.

 

MATTHEWS:  But that`s why you`re here.  I want a proclamation.  How does it

look?  All right, here is the question.  I know you`re a great reporter.

 

(Overlapping dialog)

 

SWAN:  I`ll do this for you now and it will be played on loop for the next

18 months, and Donald Trump will probably Tweet about it.  So I`m going to

leave it to the others.

 

MATTHEWS:  Let me go with somebody who may be offering an opinion tonight. 

That`s Danielle. 

$50, not going to bet any money on television, Trump or the field, somebody

beats him.  How does it look?

 

DANIELLE MOODIE-MILLS, HOST, SIRIUSXM:  How does it look?  I think that

Trump gets beat.  I mean, the polls look ridiculous.  He has – the fact

that he has never claimed the majority of Americans` support in the two-

and-a-half-years that he has been President is shocking.  The fact that he

 

MATTHEWS:  He won without it.

 

MOODIE-MILLS:  Well, let`s be clear how he won.  He had a friend in Russia

that helped him out.

 

MATTHEWS:  Really?  You think Russia did it in the election?

 

MOODIE-MILLS:  Yes, I do.  I think that Russia gave him all the help that

he wanted.  And I think he asked for it the other night with George

Stephanopoulos and said, hey, I`m open for business.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, he asked for it.  Tim, let me ask about the general

outlook for Trump, because he has these double-digit losses, deficiencies

in states we know he needs, but he did go to Florida, a state we know he

needs.  He has to start with Florida, work his way through North Carolina,

then he`s got to get some of these industrial states to win.

 

TIM O`BRIEN, BLOOMBERG OPINION EDITOR-IN-CHIEF:  Well, I don`t think the

math is complex.  If he doesn`t hold Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania,

he`s not going to win again, even – I think even if he gets Florida.  I

mean, those were the states that put him over the top the last time.  And

he was over the top in those races on a razor`s edge.

 

But I agree with Jonathan.  It`s too early.  I think even though if it`s

too early to predict whether or not he is going to win, it`s not too early

to identify what he needs to talk about and what he is going to have

difficulty talking about, the economy and healthcare.

 

And the healthcare keeps polling strongly with voters, you know, from

talking to voters in Ohio.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, it had a lot to do with `18.  It had a lot to do with `18.

 

O`BRIEN:  It had a lot to do with `18.  And on the economy, some of the

numbers are starting to look cloudy there.  And I think if the economy –

if you have recession, that`s going to be a lot of – that`s going to a big

headwind for Trump to struggle against.

 

MATTHEWS:  Let me go to Charlie Sykes on this.  Do you think the democrats

have learned their lesson?  One of the lessons we picked up again last

night, it didn`t take much effort, people don`t like being overlooked.  And

so there are people living out in states like, you know, triple A, double A

baseball towns, middle-sized towns of 100,000.  They felt that Hillary –

well, they`re right.  Hillary didn`t come there.  It`s as basic as basic

politics, show up and ask for the vote.  Do you think the democrats have

learned the lesson, if they`re going to beat Trump, first thing I`d do is

go to little towns, like Erie, Pennsylvania a couple of times, Dayton a

couple of times and show you`re respectful of those voters?  Do they know

that yet?

 

CHARLIE SYKES, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF, THE BULWARK:  And listen to what they are

actually – yes.

 

MATTHEWS:  Do they know it?

 

SYKES:  And listen to what they are actually saying.  But, look, yes, you

know – and I think that Donald Trump is in trouble.  There is no question

about it.  But I think his re-election chances are better than they look

right now, not just because it`s early, but here is somebody.  Remember how

underwater he was in 2016?  He knows he doesn`t have to win the election. 

He has to have the democrats lose the election.  And they are giving him

oppo research every single day.

 

You know, I think the healthcare issue ought to be a slam-dunk with the

democrats, but there are polls out now showing that, really, nobody

understands what do democrats mean when they say Medicare for all.  Do you

get to keep your private insurance?  Will you get to – will there be an

option?

 

MATTHEWS:  What`s the oppo that you`ve (INAUDIBLE) – you`ve entranced me

by?  You know, somebody said fascinated with Jeb Bush.  Nobody has ever

been fascinated with Jeb Bush.  I`m sorry.  That`s (INAUDIBLE) you`re

really reaching with that message.  Nobody has ever been fascinated with

Jeb Bush.

 

But let me ask you this.  Do you think they got stuff with Biden?  Do they

got stuff with – well, Bernie is sort of his own open book.  He is an old

line socialist.  If you don`t like, that you can always yell that at him. 

But I wonder if you can go after Buttigieg.  He is such a young guy, he

doesn`t have a record.  He is been openly gay.  He is married.  He puts it

all on the table.  What would be the negative on a guy like that?  I don`t

get it.  What`s the oppo?

 

SWAN:  I don`t know what they`ve got – sorry, is that for Charlie?

 

MATTHEWS:  Charlie first, then you.

 

SYKES:  Well, look, I mean, you know, we watch these guys over the last two

years.  They will come up with something on each and every one of these

candidates.  This is one of the benefits of having an alternative reality,

an incredible echo machine out there to be able to do that.  And, you know,

you may have this on two tracks.  You may have, you know, the Trump

campaign saying, we`re not going to go after Pete Buttigieg`s personal

life, and then a massive below the radar screen campaign among evangelical

Christians to smear him.

 

And so, I mean, look, this is going to be ugly.  The democrats need to

understand it`s going to be ugly.  They have to understand what the Trump

campaign is going to be about.  It`s going to Hillaryize whoever is the

nomination.  Hillary did not lose this – did not lose the election just

because of the Russians.  She lost because she didn`t ask for the votes,

and, in fact, she made herself or she was perceived by these voters to be

disconnected and toxic.  And that will be the model of the Trump campaign

whatever the democrats put up.

 

MATTHEWS:  Charlie, she also suffers from reality.  If you`ve been in

public life for 30 or 40 years, you`ve got 30, 40 years of target.  And

Hillary had that going way back to when she was First Lady.

 

O`BRIEN:  She also was in Pennsylvania.  We said earlier, you know, these

states, she was in Pennsylvania.  She may not have spent enough time in

Wisconsin and Michigan, but they spent a lot of time in Pennsylvania.

 

MATTHEWS:  Right now, the campaign in Pennsylvania for Trump said it was

like about seven to two ratio for Trump showing up.

 

And I`m going to you about this because, Danielle, I want to ask you about

the slurs.  You know, we can argue whether Pocahontas is a slur or not.  It

was a shot.  I don`t think Pocahontas was a bad person historically.  I

don`t think it`s anybody negative.  But I want to know – it didn`t work

because here he comes – he did his best shot at her, his favorite

nickname, obviously, and here she is coming on like gangbusters.

 

MOODIE-MILLS;  Yes, because she has policies and she literally has a plan

for everything.  And I think that where the democrats are going to win is

with their policies, is with their messaging.  Because just imagine Donald

Trump on the debate stage with somebody, if it`s a Warren, if it`s a

Harris, if it`s a Biden, actually talking about policy and him up there

throwing slurs and throwing, you know, character assassinations.

 

That`s not what the American people want.  His base wants that at their

rallies, but the American people, in general, don`t want that.  And his

poll numbers show that, regardless of whether or not he is trying to

gaslight everybody.

 

MATTHEWS:  I agree with you.  Jonathan, when somebody shakes off his worse

punch, you know, he made that Native American reference to Elizabeth

Warren, doesn`t that scare him, I think?  What do you think about that? 

Because he hasn`t figured out Buttigieg, he hasn`t figured out Kamala, he

may – I don`t think he thinks he has to figure out Sanders.  He is pretty

much an open book.  But I don`t think he has figured out Elizabeth Warren

either.  Warren is tough, tough cookie.  She is a tough cookie.

 

SWAN:  She is.  But, again, like she has surged within the democratic

primary electorate.  And I don`t think you know that she`s shaken off

Trump`s punch with the general electorate.  So – and we have such short-

term memory.  I think we forget that when Hillary Clinton finished her term

as Secretary of State, the nation loved her.

 

MATTHEWS:  Because she was out in politics before.  No, we know why.  Come

on, but we all know why.  She got out of the business for a while.

 

SWAN:  That`s fine, Chris.  But just remember how short a time it took for

the machine to get going and to home in on her.  And, I`m sorry, we`ve seen

that image that your other guest talked about of a candidate talking about

policy on a debate stage.  That was Hillary Clinton.  She did that.  So I

don`t know that this is some new paradigm.

 

MOODIE-MILLS:  That was her problem, is that Hillary Clinton, actually, she

was above reproach.  And she thought that she was going to be above it. 

And so she wasn`t going to try and fight back.  And that was the problem.

 

MATTHEWS:  I think I`ve finally found the right person to ask that question

today.  Okay, when he did that Godzilla number, the debate, what would you

have done?

 

MOODIE-MILLS:  Turned around and been like, what are you doing, right? 

Every woman in America, every woman in America, I`m telling you, if she had

turned around and been like what, right?  I`m actually speaking.  Every

woman in America would have applauded at that moment.  She wrote it in her

book that that was one of her biggest mistakes, that she did not confront

him and turn around and say, what are you doing.  He was stalking her on

the stage.

 

MATTHEWS:  I knew you were right.  Anyway, (INAUDIBLE) asked the question

there, thank you.  When confronted with reports about those internal

polling numbers from his own campaign, his own campaign, Trump first denied

their existence to ABC News.

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS, ABC NEWS HOST:  We`ve all seen these reports that

were 15 out of 17 states he spent 2 million on a poll and you`re behind in

15 out of 17 states.

 

DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT:  Nobody showed you those polls because those

polls don`t exist, George.  Those polls don`t exist.  But I just had a

meeting with somebody that`s a pollster, and I`m winning everywhere.

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  Tim, you pointed out in that picture that George Stephanopoulos

has got his seat belt on.

 

O`BRIEN:  Good observant democrat.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, no, it`s so Mike Dukakis and the (INAUDIBLE) seat belt on. 

Anyway, despite Trump`s insistence that those polls don`t exist, Trump`s

campaign cut ties, in other words, fired some of the pollsters after the

data was leaked.  Tim, that`s a riot.  Talk about blaming the messenger. 

What to do with bad poll numbers?  Fire the pollster.

 

O`BRIEN:  Well, this is classic Trump, right?  Jonathan had a scoop tonight

that the White House had known for a month that they had problems with

Shanahan, and Trump said he only found out recently.  Trump said he believe

tariffs affect consumers.  He believes the Mueller report exonerated him. 

And he`s now saying that the poll numbers, his own poll numbers aren`t what

they say they are.

 

The trick to Trump is that he creates alternative realities.  And his

strength is that he is happy to exist in those.

 

MATTHEWS:  Okay.  You`ve got Jonathan.  You`ve just been teased here.  I

tell you, when you broke the story about Shanahan, the acting, acting,

acting but never real Secretary of Defense and his marital history and all

that stuff, Trump says, I wanted to let him have more time with his family,

which is the code for, I fired the guy.  And everybody knows that code. 

You`ve been fired.  What`s the reality there?

 

SWAN:  He wasn`t fired.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, then why did the President say, to say to spend more time

with his family?

 

SWAN:  Well, I can`t get to that, but, honestly, Trump was prepared to

support him if he wanted to.  Shanahan went to the Oval Office today.  Even

as early as this morning, like early this morning, some senior White House

officials still thought he was committed to going through with it.  And

they had a conversation in the Oval, and then Patrick Shanahan said to

President Trump that it just wasn`t going to work out with his family.

 

MATTHEWS:  Did the president ask him to stick it out?

 

SWAN:  The President said, if you want to stay, I will support you.

 

MATTHEWS:  If you want to stay.  But if you want to say, I`ll support you

is not an endorsement.

 

SWAN:  He did not ask him to step down in a way that he has with others.

 

MATTHEWS:  But he didn`t ask him to stay either.

 

SWAN:  The thing that`s most unbelievable to me is president telling

reporters that he only found out about this yesterday.  I know for a fact

that senior White House officials, including that White House Counsel`s

Office have known about this for more than a month, the divorce

allegations.  So I find it very hard to believe that the President only

found it about this yesterday.

 

MATTHEWS:  Okay.  Well, anyway, in his interview with ABC News, the

President highlighted three themes to win over undecided voters next year. 

Here he goes.

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

STEPHANOPOULOS:  What`s your pitch to the swing voter on the fence?

 

TRUMP:  Safety, security, great economy.

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  But new reporting shows that Trump`s actions could undercut the

strength of those messages.  On safety, escalating tensions with Iran have

prompted an additional deployment of another thousand troops over to the

Middle East.  Not exactly a peaceful move.  And it relates to security. 

We`re learning that officials dealing with the Russian cyber threat

reportedly felt the need to withhold information on that from the

President, the Commander-in-Chief.

 

According to The New York Times, the Pentagon and intelligence officials

describe broad hesitation to go into detail with Mr. Trump about operations

against Russia for concern over his reaction and the possibility that he

might countermand it or discuss it with foreign officials.  Charlie, my

thoughts, he`s Commander-in-Chief.  I`m just reading this book on

Roosevelt.  He insisted on being Commander-in-Chief, not taking orders from

the joint chiefs or the defense secretary, but being in charge of our

military operation.  Now, we find out that our cyber war is being conducted

under the table and out of sight of the President.

 

SYKES:  That is an extraordinary – that was an extraordinary buried lead

in that particular story, the fact that they don`t tell the President about

this because he might countermand it or leak it to the hostile foreign

power that we`re actually engaged with, so, yes.

 

And there are a lot of vulnerabilities.  And Tim mentioned before what

happens if the economy goes down.  But to go through his themes, you know,

of safety, security and the economy, the flipside of all of that is the

democrats are threats to all of that.  They are weak.  They are for open

borders.  They won`t protect you and they`re going to trash the economy

through socialism.  You`re going to see that two-track campaign that Trump

is going to do.

 

And even though he`s got the vulnerabilities, you know, I know that

everybody is talking about all the policies and the plans that Elizabeth

Warren has.  But one of the things that Trump, I think, understands

intuitively is that these elections are decided by the big, bold colors,

not the details.  And he`s going to try to shape this with these big, broad

themed figuring that the swing voters aren`t going to sweat the details.

 

MATTHEWS:  You know, when you`re a kid in high school and you have

fistfights at recess, you have braces, for example, like I did, your other

guy punches you right in the teeth all the time because he knows you`ll be

a hamburger at the end of the fight.  Trump knows that.  He goes for the

vulnerable, the bad eye, the weakness, the physical embarrassment, whatever

it is.  Okay, open borders, late-term on abortion rights, late-term, which

is really troubling to a lot of people, morally (ph), and socialism.  One

of the opponent is Joe Biden, or it`s Buttigieg or somebody that is not

known to be on the hard left.  What does he do then?  Charlie?

 

SYKES:  Well, I mean, he`ll paint whoever it is in those colors.  I mean,

every single person has a vulnerability.  And you`re absolutely right.  One

of the things that Donald Trump has mastered is to find that vulnerability. 

What is the cartoon image that he can pin on that individual.  And, you

know, until you`re actually tested in a general election, who knows.  We`ve

made a career out of underestimating Donald Trump, right?

 

And so, you know, the one thing that he had is he does have that bully

instinct.  What is the vulnerability, what is the weak spot, how can I

hammer away at that?  And the fact that he is utterly without shame and

utterly without scruple gives him an advantage in American politics today,

unfortunately.

 

MATTHEWS:  Danielle, I grew up knowing how bullies work.  There was one

frightening bully, like Mr. T in the movies, but the real guy was Sonny

Liston.  He was in prison his whole life.  He was fighting – nobody wanted

to fight Sonny Liston.  They wouldn`t fight him.  I`d knock him out, he

never fought again.  So who has the knockout punch to take down the bully?

 

MOODIE-MILLS:  I think a couple of them do.  I think that Biden can knock

him out.  I think Warren can knock him out.  I think Kamala can put him on

his behind.  Look, I think that there are several people that can.  The

reality is that we have to paint Donald Trump as Donald Trump has painted

himself.  He is erratic, he is unstable and he is unreliable, right?  And

he is a threat to America`s national security.  That`s how the democrats

need to paint him.  And if they do, they win.

 

MATTHEWS:  You should run for parliament.  I`m just teasing you.  You`re

very strong, and I like strong, because I think it`s that kind of very

self-confident aggressive ray approach to this guy would knock him on his

heels because he wouldn`t be ready for it.

 

Thank you, Danielle Moodie-Mills.  Thank you Tim O`Brien.  Thank you

Jonathan Swan and Charlie Sykes.

 

Coming up, another House member calls for impeachment, but democrats are

still a long way away critical mass (ph).  I think there are over some 230

democrats in the House.  Now, we`re up to 66, about one in four, one in

five.  It`s not enough.  Who is going to win, impeachment or the calendar,

because is going to be July soon?  When are they going to impeach this guy? 

Senator and presidential candidate Amy Klobuchar, she`s going to join us

and talk about that and other things.

 

Plus, next week`s democratic debate is the first big benchmark.  It`s a

landmark of the 2020 campaign, sort of like the All-Star game.  Are the

candidates going into it with a big moment?  I know who.  She is right

there on the right. 

 

And our very revealing discussion last night in Dayton, Ohio with The

Deciders.

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE:  That dude lies.  He lies.  The FEC Chair just had to

call him out.

 

MATTHEWS:  Do you think Trump looks out for you?

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  Absolutely.

 

MATTHEWS:  He cares about you?

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  I think he`s honest.  I think he`s true.

 

MATTHEWS:  Thank you.

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, one of the takeaways last night, republicans know the

President is not a good guy, but they know support him anyway.  Crickets

when I asked who thinks he doesn`t lie.  None of them thinks he doesn`t

lie.  Much more ahead, stick with us.

 

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

MATTHEWS:  Welcome back to HARDBALL. 

 

As President Trump officially launches his 2020 campaign tonight, calls to

start an impeachment inquiry into the president grew a bit louder today. 

 

California Congresswoman Katie Porter is the latest lawmaker to come out in

support of an impeachment inquiry, in other words, get started on

impeachment.  Porter, a Democrat who narrowly flipped her Southern

California district in this year`s midterm election – last year`s –

argued that the president`s stonewall of congressional investigations had

brought the country to a crisis.  That was her phrase.

 

Porter is now the 67th member of the U.S. House of Representatives to call

for impeachment, 66 Democrats and one Republican.  But Porter is only the

second Democrat from a Republican-leaning district to do so, along with New

Jersey`s Tom Malinowski. 

 

Well, last week, Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar said she would support an

impeachment proceeding beginning now and that the House is on the right

track with investigations. 

 

Senator Klobuchar released her 100-day plan, by the way, today, laying out

a number of actions she plans to take if she wins the White House.  We will

have more on that coming up. 

 

Democratic candidate for president Senator Amy Klobuchar joins me now. 

 

Thank you. 

 

SEN. AMY KLOBUCHAR (D-MN), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE:  Thanks, Chris. 

 

MATTHEWS:  You`re always smiling when you come on this show, at least, and

I appreciate that.

 

KLOBUCHAR:  Well, you`re fun to listen to. 

 

Thanks.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, you know, I think this.  I think the calendar is moving. 

 

I think – I watched – the older I get, the faster that calendar moves, I

got to tell you.  And, all of a sudden, it`s going to be July, it`s going

to be August. 

 

Do you think there is enough time to begin an impeachment, if we start –

unless we start fairly soon?

 

KLOBUCHAR:  The House is doing its investigation, Chris. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes, but…

 

KLOBUCHAR:  As you point out on your show, they`re going to hear from…

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes. 

 

KLOBUCHAR:  … a critical witness this week.  I know they`re still pushing

to get Mueller.  I personally think they should subpoena Robert Mueller to

testify. 

 

But I can tell you one thing we can`t wait on, and that is protecting our

election, 500 some days from now, from foreign powers or from others that

might try to hack in.

 

We know now that they`re investigating two counties in Florida, North

Carolina.  And yet the Republicans are stonewalling the Secure Elections

Act, which simply would require backup paper ballots in the 14 states that

either don`t have them or have partial. 

 

And there`s just no excuse for this, if you believe in democracy, whether

you`re a Democrat or Republican.

 

MATTHEWS:  Is it too rough a question?  But I will put it to you anyway,

Senator.

 

Do you think the president has abused his office, the powers of the

presidency?  Has he abused them? 

 

KLOBUCHAR:  I think he has, yes.  And I think, when…

 

MATTHEWS:  Do you think he`s committed impeachable crimes?

 

KLOBUCHAR:  I have made this very clear, that I believe they should start

impeachment proceedings…

 

MATTHEWS:  OK. 

 

KLOBUCHAR:  … because of the fact that we have got those 10 instances of

obstruction of justice, which form a pattern. 

 

But we also just had last week, when he actually called on foreign agents. 

He basically said, yes, if they give me dirt on an opponent…

 

MATTHEWS:  Sure.

 

KLOBUCHAR:  … I will take it.

 

Then he tries to dial it back.  To me, that was just one more message, just

like he did during the campaign. 

 

But the problem with all this, Chris, if we just dwell on this, people

aren`t going to hear what I think is the alternative future for our

country.  And that is an America that is based on our values, that brings

us forward, that is focused on what I think people want to hear about,

which is an optimistic economic agenda, where they can be part of this

country and the prosperity, because he has made so many promises.

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes. 

 

KLOBUCHAR:  As you guys just pointed out, he has promised this economy, and

so many people aren`t part of it.  He`s promised security. 

 

And, at this very moment, we are a month away from – Iran has now said

they`re going to get closer to a nuclear weapon.  When this guy came into

power, he wasn`t there. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Senator, something just broke in the news.

 

KLOBUCHAR:  OK, what?

 

MATTHEWS:  I`m sorry.  I`m listening to everything. 

 

I have just got to ask you about something that just broke in the news. 

 

The president again refused to apologize, when given the opportunity late

today, in the role he played in lobbying for the execution, the capital

punishment, of those youngsters, those teenagers who were accused in the

Central Park 5.

 

In 1989, Trump took out a full-page ad in four newspapers – there`s one of

them – calling for the execution, ending the lives of those teenagers,

four black and one Hispanic, accused of raping and beating a jogger in

Central Park. 

 

The teenagers were convicted, but later exonerated by DNA evidence, actual

innocence there, and another man`s confession.  They agreed to a $41

million settlement with New York City in 2014.  And the story is back in

the news because of the Netflix series about the cause, “When They See Us.”

 

Let`s take a look for a second here. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES:  Why do you bring that

question up now?  It`s an interesting time to bring it up. 

 

(CROSSTALK)

 

TRUMP:  You have people on both sides of that.  They admitted their guilt. 

 

If you look at Linda Fairstein, and if you look at some of the prosecutors,

they think that the city should never have settled that case.  So, we will

leave it at that. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  What do you make of that, a president against the established

DNA, scientific evidence, of actual innocence, not an argument that it was

badly prosecuted, but actual innocence, and he still sticks to saying they

should be executed? 

 

KLOBUCHAR:  Well, as a former prosecutor, I cannot tell you how offensive

it is. 

 

Our job is to do justice, to be ministers of justice, to do our job without

fear or favor.  And the same should be said as the president of the United

States. 

 

There was clear evidence here.  They have been exonerated.  And now he

comes out and says this.  I can`t even – I just think – he has said

10,000 lies.  And it`s one of the reasons that I have come out with what

you can do in your first 100 days. 

 

You just can`t wait.  Yes, we can introduce the bills.  And I`m going to do

it.  Immigration reform, I think we can get that done by the end of the

year. 

 

There`s immediate things we can do to stop this assault on people`s health

care, to make sure that we get the international climate change agreement

signed back into that on day one. 

 

And I literally have come up with 100 things we can do within those first

100 days, because there is an urgency right now to this election that goes

way beyond any other election we have seen.

 

MATTHEWS:  OK.

 

Eight days from now, Senator, you`re going to have your first chance to

reach a national audience, not just on MSNBC, but on NBC as well, and

Telemundo.

 

A lot of people have never seen you before.  They`re going to get a chance

eight days from now. 

 

You`re going to be standing out there.  We have the positions tonight.  We

know where you`re going to be.  You`re going to be standing between Beto

O`Rourke and Tulsi Gabbard of Hawaii.

 

How are you going to get your – what`s your – you only get a couple

minutes to start this discussion.  What are you going to lead with?  Come

on.  Tell us.

 

KLOBUCHAR:  Well, I want to focus – I`m not going to tell you and be the

pundit to my debate and give everything away.  Oh, no.

 

But I think it`s important that every candidate up there makes it clear

what their vision is, what they want to get done, that we talk about the

issues that matter to people, and that there`s going to be some

disagreements, but I think there`s going to be a lot more that unify

people.

 

And the number one thing is, we have to win.  We have to beat Donald Trump. 

And I will be making my case for I am that person.  I`m from the heartland. 

I`m someone that`s won every red congressional district in my state,

statewide. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, you get it. 

 

Thank you so much, U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota.

 

KLOBUCHAR:  Thank you. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Up next, Steve Kornacki takes us over to the Big Board, as we

count down to that big debate eight days from now down in Miami. 

 

Who`s got the momentum?  That`s always the big question.  Before the All-

Star Game, which teams are doing well?  Who`s got the momentum as a

candidate?  Where will everybody be standing on that stage?

 

We`re going to figure out having they`re going to physically look like each

other.  You got to go with the person to your right or your left.

 

You`re watching HARDBALL. 

 

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

TRUMP:  Rand Paul shouldn`t even be on this stage.  He`s number 11.  He`s

got 1 percent in the polls.  And how he got up here, there`s far too many

people.

 

I`m at like 42, and you`re at 3.  So, so far, I`m doing better. 

 

JEB BUSH (R), FORMER FLORIDA GOVERNOR:  Doesn`t matter.  Doesn`t matter.

 

(CHEERING AND APPLAUSE)

 

TRUMP:  So far, I`m doing better. 

 

You started off over here, Jeb.  You`re moving over further and further. 

Pretty soon, you`re going to be off the end. 

 

I was center stage in every debate.  You know the way guys kept falling off

the ends?  You know, they kept falling off. 

 

I said, Jeb, you`re not going to be here much longer.  You`re pretty far

down there, Jeb. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  Welcome back to HARDBALL. 

 

That was, of course, then candidate Donald Trump relishing his advantage of

being center stage during the primary debates. 

 

Well, today, we found out exactly where each Democratic candidate will

stand in the debate next week. 

 

MSNBC national political correspondent Steve Kornacki is here with more –

Steve. 

 

STEVE KORNACKI, MSNBC NATIONAL POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT:  Yes, Chris, we can

take you through it. 

 

Here`s the lineup, first night next week, Wednesday night.  And you see,

they align these candidates here, the 10 on stage.  They basically did the

order based on the polling, working from the outside in, so 10th among this

group, ninth, eighth, seventh and so forth.  And it works its way all the

way to the middle. 

 

That`s where Elizabeth Warren – she`s the highest polling candidate in

this first-night group.  That`s where she`s going to be, to one side of

her, Cory Booker, to the other side, Beto O`Rourke.  That is sort of the

middle of the stage there.  And, of course, then that`s Wednesday night.

 

Thursday night, the second night, that is when the – oh, I have got to

turn the marker off here – that is when the bigger names in terms of

polling are all on stage together, Buttigieg, Biden, Sanders, Harris, all

four of them, four of the top five right now by polling, all going to be

right there in the middle of the stage. 

 

There`s the former vice president.  He`s got Bernie Sanders on one side,

Pete Buttigieg on the other.  So that`s the lineup there, Chris, for each

night next week.

 

MATTHEWS:  What do you make about that second night? 

 

I just think about all the B`s there, Biden and Bernie and Buttigieg, and

then Harris.  It seems to me that somebody is going to take on somebody

very close to them physically.  It`s going to be fascinating.

 

KORNACKI:  It is.

 

And so much of the energy on stage is going to be sort of directed from the

outside toward the middle, because I think these other candidates are all

going to be trying to get their moment in the limelight. 

 

We were looking back at past debate moments today.  Here`s one you may

remember, Hillary Clinton back in the 2008.  Remember the driver`s license

question that really tripped her up in that campaign?  Remember who really

instigated that moment?  It was Chris Dodd. 

 

It was one of the candidates who was kind of on the periphery, wasn`t

really registering, but he was on stage.  And he had the chance.  And in

that moment, he really made things uncomfortable for Hillary Clinton. 

 

And that`s – that`s one of the questions I have for some of these other

candidates on the outside here.  Do they pursue something like that?

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes, I thought that was like a double – doubling up on her in

basketball, like two-manning her.  I thought that was interesting, because

I – taken by the fact that Biden, who was technically still running – he

still wanted to win the presidency – he backed up Obama against Hillary.

 

KORNACKI:  And ended up getting the V.P. slot.  There you go.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, I guess he got paid for that. 

 

(LAUGHTER)

 

MATTHEWS:  Let`s talk about the – about the president and what he`s up to,

because we have looked at all these numbers today.  And I remain skeptical

that this guy is as easy to beat as the numbers show.

 

Your thoughts, looking at the newest numbers?

 

KORNACKI:  Yes.

 

Take it through – I mean, look, this is his average approval rating.  You

take every poll that`s out there right now on his approval, and it clocks

in at 43.9 percent.  And you would normally look at that, a president in

that territory, and say, well, that president`s going to be in trouble next

year for reelection. 

 

The interesting thing about Trump is, he`s pretty much lived in that range

his entire presidency.  His high point as president, his high watermark,

this is his honeymoon.  He hit 46 percent about two weeks in, in early

2017.  His low watermark, 37 percent.

 

He`s existed almost entirely within that range.  The thing to keep in mind,

Chris, though, is, this is also the range that Donald Trump lived in during

the 2016 presidential campaign. 

 

If you had taken polls throughout the fall of 2016, on a bad day, he was

down here.  On a really good day, he was getting close to this territory. 

Usually, he was somewhere in between.  And when you got to Election Day,

2016, you had exit polls showing that folks had all sorts of negative

opinions about Donald Trump, off-the-charts negative in some cases.

 

And yet the negatives for his opponent in the end were just high enough,

his favorable rating was just high enough, he was able to stitch together

that path. 

 

It`s a completely open question to me if he can pull that off again in

2020. 

 

MATTHEWS:  What do you think about the accuracy?  I mean, I keep thinking,

well-spoken, articulate pollsters call up with standard English sort of

accents.  They call up a person who is a bit conservative, who – maybe not

have all the education as the person who`s calling them as.

 

And you go, where are you on this election?  And the person who gets the

call goes, I`m not going to tell you, wise guy.  You`re a big shot.  You

probably went to an Ivy League school.  I`m not going to tell you what I

think.  I like Trump, but I`m not going to tell you. 

 

Is that going on?  Or is there any way to find that in the polling and fix

for it? 

 

KORNACKI:  To the extent you`re saying, that is tough to find for, but I

think a lot of people have suspicions.

 

And the other thing is, it`s just a simple question of, people have

conflicting views of Trump, I think.  You saw that in the exit polls. 

People who did not think he was qualified to be president, they said that

in the exit poll – I don`t think Trump`s qualified – some of them still

voted for him. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes, like, last night, they said – they wouldn`t say he doesn`t

lie.  They would all say he`s crass.  They don`t think their kids should

behave like him.  And then they`re not going to move. 

 

And I think your poll shows that.  They`re hard as a rock. 

 

KORNACKI:  Yes. 

 

MATTHEWS:  And it`s low 40s, but it`s still rock.

 

And, Steve, you`re the best.  Nobody`s got anybody like you, nobody.

 

KORNACKI:  Hey, Chris. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Except, we do.

 

Up next:  What were some of the big takeaways from last night`s “Deciders”

town hall in Dayton, Ohio, just last night?  Some voters` views on Trump`s

honesty and accomplishments, as I said, could surprise you.

 

The Trumpies admit the worst about him.

 

You`re watching HARDBALL. 

   

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

 

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

CHRIS MATTHEWS, MSNBC HOST:  Welcome back to HARDBALL.

 

Last night, we were in Dayton, Ohio, part of Montgomery County, which voted

for Barack Obama.  As we said last night many times, twice, and then

flipped to Trump last time, to get a sense of what a diverse group of

voters like that were thinking about. 

 

With the election 16 months away now, here`s what they had to say about

Trump. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE:  I definitely do not, and I feel that he actually ran

on promoting racism. 

 

(APPLAUSE)

 

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE:  And anybody who flipped for him is somebody who

supports people who don`t support people of color. 

 

MATTHEWS:  You think Trump looks out for you? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  Absolutely. 

 

MATTHEWS:  He cares about you? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  Yes. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Thank you. 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  I think he is honest.  I think he is true. 

 

BILL MASON, MARKETING EXECUTIVE:  We have people who stand up for

institutions, stand up for America, make the promises to uphold and defend

the Constitution.  And Donald Trump has not ever been that person. 

 

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE:  It`s hard to try to find where you fit when everyone

wants to be in a category. 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  Every politician calls other politicians names.  We

have them on hot mic for 30 years.  They all do that.  This guy at least

does it up front. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, there were also some lively exchanges between supporters

and critics of the commander-in-chief.  Let`s take a look at that. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  I mean, what`s wrong with putting America first because

we have all these old trade agreements that are like NAFTA that took a lot

of jobs. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Do you think he honors the Constitution? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  Pardon?  What`s that again? 

 

MATTHEWS:  Does he honor the Constitution? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  I believe he honors the Constitution. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Everybody else agree? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED MALE:  He took an oath.  He took an oath to honor the

Constitution. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Thank you, sir.  Let me go to another person here.  Back here. 

Do you want to respond to what he just said? 

 

UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE:  I most certainly do.  He does not honor the

Constitution.  And I can tell you a couple of places where he doesn`t. 

Number one, Article I, Section 9, the Emoluments Clause.  Let`s go for

that. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, I asked the voters in Dayton, Republicans and Democrats,

how many of them think Trump lies.  Their response spoke volumes.  That`s

coming up next.

 

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

MATTHEWS:  Welcome back to HARDBALL.

 

Last night during our “Deciders” town hall in Dayton, Ohio, an area that

voted twice for Obama and then for Trump last time, I asked the audience of

Democrats and Republicans what they thought of the president`s, here`s the

word, truthfulness. 

 

Listen to what they said, or rather didn`t say. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  OK, how many people here don`t think Trump lies? 

 

AUDIENCE:  Say that again? 

 

MATTHEWS:  How many people here don`t think Trump lies?  I thought it was

interesting silence. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  That was absolute crickets.  No one in the room of mixed

Republican and Democrat, not a single clap or noise of any kind said they

don`t think he lies. 

 

I`m now joined with Michelle Goldberg, “New York Times” columnist, and Noah

Rothman, he`s associate editor of “Commentary”. 

 

Thank you, both.  I mean, you write for magazines and “New York Times”

where you have to write the truth.  I mean, that`s the deal. 

 

The facts have to be – but this crowd, I`m not talking about the Democrat

people, the passionate progressives.  I`m talking about people that stood

up and stood up for Trump, but did not defend his word.  They don`t defend

his word. 

 

MICHELLE GOLDBERG, MSNBC CONTRIBUTOR:  Right.  I think the division in this

country is not between people who think Trump lies and people who don`t. 

It`s between people who care that Trump lies and people who don`t. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Why don`t the people who are supportive of him believe it`s

important to tell the truth? 

 

GOLDBERG:  Because they think he is getting away with it, right?  They

think when he lies, he is lying on behalf of their interests.  And I also

think –

 

MATTHEWS:  You`re so smart because one of the guys said does it matter that

he lies?  As long as Mitch McConnell was the judge. 

 

GOLDBERG:  Right.  I also think that they get a perverse – not all of

them, but I think there are some conservatives who get a perverse sort of

glee at watching the rest of us get so apoplectic as he lies continually

and shamelessly, and there is nothing we can do about it.  I think they

sort of like the fact that it torments the half of the country that can`t

bear it. 

 

MATTHEWS:  What happens when he says the polls aren`t really true, the ones

that leaked weren`t really the polls and then fires his pollsters this

week? 

 

NOAH ROTHMAN, MSNBC CONTRIBUTOR:  Yes, that was a very strange moment. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Threatens to fire Sean Spicer for saying the crowd wasn`t as big

as he wanted it to be. 

 

ROTHMAN:  There is a reason why you would release internal polls that show

you behind, right?  It has instrumental utility.  It fires up your donors. 

You can fundraise off of it.  You can get your voters energized. 

 

You don`t fire the guys who do it because they`re doing a service for you. 

It suggests that he doesn`t really understand campaigning in a way he

really should. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes, polls operate differently. 

 

ROTHMAN:  This is probably more in line with his personality. 

 

MATTEHWS:  One of the people we spoke to last night, an independent, had

this warning to the more than 20 Democrats running for president.  Let`s

watch this warning.

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

DAN MOORMAN (I), VOTED FOR TRUMP IN 2016:  The reason Trump is president in

my opinion is because of his competition.  Hillary was just worse.  Y`all

were talking about Trump.  The fact of the matter he is an egotistical,

self-centered human being that happened to have a worse competitor. 

 

I want some good options.  I want some good options and I haven`t really

seen them. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  What do you think of that guy, Michelle?

 

GOLDBERG:  Well, I thought the rest of his comment is he is angry because

he feels that people are stealing from him. 

 

MATTHEWS:  He said that,             you had a U.S. senator there, Sherrod Brown,

he said, tell your buddies and you to stop stealing from me. 

 

GOLDBERG:  Right.  So, you know, to be honest, if what you really want is -

- if you really kind of resent having to pay taxes and pay the taxes that

support all the social programs that people in polls also say they want,

it`s true that sort of neither party is offering you anything.  I think

that man said that he was thinking about voting libertarian. 

 

But I also think – 

 

MATTHEWS:  Yes, Gary Johnson.  But he also said he was in a booth.  This I

never heard of.  It may be hyperbole.  He said he was in the booth for 30

minutes. 

 

I was kidding because I know when I`m voting, you got to move the crowd

along a little bit.  He said I took 30 minutes to decide I hated Hillary

more than Trump. 

 

GOLDBERG:  I think he knows that voting for Trump was a morally compromised

– a morally compromised act.  And also, once you do something like that,

something that you do know is wrong you then have to justify it

retroactively. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Look, I think it`s a preview of what`s coming.  I think Trump

doesn`t want to be the issue in 2020.  He wants the Democrat candidate to

be the ultimate issue.  He`ll go after them on looks, he`ll go after them

on ideology, on baggage.  He will find something to make that person less

unlikable than he is. 

 

ROTHMAN:  It would be extremely smart to do that, and that`s why I`m not

banking on that.  I think his instinct is to make the election the

referendum on him.  That`s what he did in 2018.  He wrested it from the

hands of Republicans who were making it a referendum on Democrats to say I

want to talk about the border. 

 

And as for that guy who is a swing voter, he really is the quintessential

swing voter.  Swing voters don`t vote on ideological reasons.  Americans

don`t love to have their income taken from them in the form of taxes. 

Ideologues like that.  Democrat voters like that.  Swing voters vote on the

guy they saw most recently. 

 

(CROSSTALK)

 

MATTHEWS:  The guy they saw most recently? 

 

ROTHMAN:  Macroeconomic issues, sentimentality, and, yes, pressing the

flesh of retail politics.  That matters to swing voters.

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, I think I saw them, what you mean by, did they show up and

show respect for you. 

 

President Trump is said to make the economy a central part of his 2020

reelection campaign.  Last night I asked the audience if the Republicans`

$1.5 trillion tax cut which Trump said would be rocket fuel for the economy

actually helped them personally or they saw anything in their life that

reflected it. 

 

Let`s take a look at what they said. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  There was a tax bill passed last year.  I want to know, put your

hands up if you come up with any discernible improvement in the situation

because of the tax cut.  Put your hand up. 

 

Wow.  That`s about 10 people in the room here at the most. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  What it is that stops people – well, we know that the

unemployment rate dropped about two points in that county since Trump came

in.  I don`t know if he had anything to do with it, but the economy has

helped.  We know you make an extra buck an hour there, about 28 bucks as

opposed to 27 bucks an hour.  Some modest improvement in people`s salaries,

very modest, 4 percent, but only 10 people said improvement in their lives. 

 

GOLDBERG:  Well, from the tax cut, right?  And I think you can`t

necessarily connect lowered unemployment rate to the tax cut. 

 

MATTHEWS:  You think they`re just talking about the refund they got? 

 

GOLDBERG:  Yes, I think people see they got very little.  Then they read

about the stock buybacks, they read about the massive amounts that people

in Donald Trump`s tax bracket got.  And also I think there is a lot of

research –

 

MATTHEWS:  I don`t think they know what you know.  You said stocks buyback

is a big issue ideologically.

 

GOLDBERG:  So they might not know what stock buybacks are, but they

definitely understand that Wall Street made out much better than they did. 

I also think there is a lot of research now that people`s perceptions of

the economy is being somewhat decoupled from or is increasingly tied to

their partisan affiliations. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Agreed. 

 

GOLDBERG:  The economy there are so many different signals, you read them

depending where your loyalties are. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Well, Michelle, and here`s my prediction, Trump will spend $1

billion, maybe $2 billion if he`s got it, to sell America on the better

economy and what he did.  You can do that with money. 

 

I went through Morning in America.  Reagan had a 7-plus unemployment and he

sold the country on the fact we are gangbusters.  So it can be done with

advertising. 

 

Thank you so much, Michelle Goldberg.

 

GOLDBERG:  Thank you.

 

MATTHEWS:  And thank you, Noah Rothman. 

 

Up next, I sat down with Steve Colbert on “The Late Show” tonight.  I have

a preview what`s coming tonight.  They just taped. 

 

You`re watching HARDBALL.

 

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

 

MATTHEWS:  I`m going to be on “The Late Show” tonight with Stephen Colbert,

and here is a bit of our discussion on Trump and his 2020 opponents. 

 

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

 

STEPHEN COLBERT, HOST, THE LATE SHOW:  If Trump launched his reelection

campaign today.  OK, it`s happening as we speak in Orlando, Florida. 

 

MATTHEWS:  Disneyworld. 

 

COLBERT:  Yes, going on down there. 

 

MATTHEWS:  I`m worried.  I think it`s going to be a real close one next

November.  I think two or three of the Democrats I can see beating him. 

Others may beat him.  I think Biden could beat him.  I think Warren could

beat him.  I think Buttigieg is coming on strong. 

 

I think right now it`s like Baskin Robbins.  You go in, there is 31

flavors.  I tried Beto last week.  I think I`ll try Buttigieg.  It`s like a

tasting thing. 

 

(END VIDEO CLIP)

 

MATTHEWS:  That`s HARDBALL for now.  Thanks for being with us. 

 

“ALL IN WITH CHRIS HAYES” starts right now. 

 

 

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY

BE UPDATED.

END   

 

Copyright 2019 ASC Services II Media, LLC.  All materials herein are

protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced,

distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the

prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter

or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the

content.>