Hardball with Chris Matthews, Transcript 9/29/17 Tom Price resigns as Health Secretary
Date: September 29, 2017
Guest: Toluse Olorunnipa, Ken Vogel, Kamar de los Reyes, Jenna Johnson,
Clarence Page, Dan Diamond, Peter Baker, Eliza Collins, Kurt Bardella,
Seung Min Kim, Sally Quinn
CHRIS MATTHEWS, HOST: Swamped.
Let`s play HARDBALL.
Good evening. I`m Chris Matthews in Washington.
President Trump saw the mud clinging to his brand and didn`t like how it
looked to the country, including the Trump people. Or maybe, just maybe,
it was the smell of the swamp, as well, the smell of the rot at the top, of
big shots using private and military jets to ease their official trips.
Maybe it was that, too, that led him to what he`s just done.
Tonight, President Trump fired Health and Human Services secretary Tom
Price after Price was unable to justify his decision to use private planes
for otherwise routine travel. Driven by a series of investigative reports
by Politico, the stories of the secretary`s travel expenses caused an
uproar that ultimately the former secretary could not contain.
The behavior that those reports exposed threatened to tarnish further a
president who famously vowed to drain the swamp. Here`s how President
Trump expressed his displeasure with his now former secretary late today
just minutes before Price was officially gone.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: He`s a very fine man, but
we`re going to make a decision some time tonight. We are looking into it,
and we`re looking into it very strongly. I`m not happy, OK? I can tell
you I`m not happy. OK.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: Well, in firing Price, President Trump sent a strong signal that
he won`t tolerate government excesses, at least when they embarrass him.
Now former secretary Price joins a growing list of top Trump advisers and
officials to depart this administration over the last eight months.
Joining me right now is Peter Baker, chief White House correspondent for
“The New York Times,” Dan Diamond, reporter with Politico who first broke
this story – in fact, he broke it about Price`s private plane trips, and
Jenna Johnson`s a White House reporter with “The Washington Post” and my
friend, Clarence Page, columnist with “The Chicago Tribune.”
Let`s get your take. First of all, Dan, congratulations on breaking a
story that`s made news here now and has changed the shape of this cabinet.
Did they know when you broke the story about his use of private planes,
which cost about $300,000 or $400,000, not the $30,000 or $50,000 he
claimed it did, and then it turns out another half million dollars in
military planes of questionable use in this case – did they know they had
stepped on it?
DAN DIAMOND, POLITICO: They didn`t realize how much we had when we first
reported it, Chris. They told the White House this would be a one-day
story. They played us off.
MATTHEWS: Who said it was a one-day story?
DIAMOND: Well, the HHS press people to the White House press people, which
I think was part of the problem that got us to today. The White House felt
ambushed that they didn`t have a full picture, and by the time that HHS and
Price responded, it had already become a mushrooming scandal.
MATTHEWS: Peter, tell me what you think went into Trump`s head because he
seemed to have gotten the smell of this several days ago. It wasn`t like
he erupted this Friday night. You know, you dump the garbage in politics
in Washington on Friday night, we all know that, because they think people
don`t read the Saturday paper, which is nonsense. I happen to like your
paper a lot on Saturday morning because it`s filled with news like this,
people getting fired on Friday night. Of course…
PETER BAKER, “NEW YORK TIMES”: Politico will have that, too.
MATTHEWS: Yes, Politico had that. But you know, I like the paper in front
of me, OK, on Saturdays. Peter, tell me why you think that Trump – who`s
covered up and put up with a lot of crap, but this thing seemed to have
gotten to his nose and his eyes. This looks and smells bad, this big-shot
BAKER: Well, there are two things to remember. First of all, Mr. Price
was already sort of in trouble anyway with the president because for
months, he`s been seething about the failure to pass legislation to repeal
and replace the Affordable Care Act, President Obama`s health care plan.
He blamed Tom Price for that at least in part.
So when this came up, there wasn`t the reservoir of good will. And then as
you say, it affected his brand. One of the most important things he is
looking at in terms of his base is this “drain the swamp” image that he
brings to the table. And this has been a bad week for that, with the
Luther Strange defeat in the Alabama primary, the president found himself
on the opposite end of his base on two big things, and the latest failure
in the Senate to pass health care legislation. So at the end of a bad
week, he felt the need, I think, to get control of his public image again.
MATTHEWS: Jenna, I agree. It`s become sort of the capstone of the week.
But let`s talk about the big picture. Trump, as he just said, he`s fired
the guy. He`s heading to another airplane, another weekend at some luxury
spot like Mar-a-Lago or up in New Jersey at his golf – all paid for by the
federal government – big plane, by the way, not a little one but a gas
eater, a big one.
He seems to have no compunction – he flies his family, Jared and Ivanka,
all around the world. They go to Asia, Africa, everywhere, all at
government expense with huge entourages. You know, they aren`t the
Romanovs. Now, this guy, Price, may behave like an oligarch. He and his
family behave like the Romanovs.
How can – where`s the consistency here in the splurging of taxpayers`
money and it only is that Price pays the price?
JENNA JOHNSON, “WASHINGTON POST”: Well, when it comes with Trump, a lot of
that has been explained away by saying it`s security, that the president
MATTHEWS: How about spending one weekend a year in the White House? That
would save a few bucks…
JOHNSON: It would.
MATTHEWS: … like one weekend. He`s never been there on a weekend.
JOHNSON: Yes. I mean, those complaints are adding up and adding up. But
with the president`s base, they have a lot of tolerance when it comes to
the president. They think that he should be able to work wherever he
wants, that his family should be protected. Where people start to get
angry is where they see someone like the health secretary, who they might
not have even really known that person`s name.
MATTHEWS: Some lower form of life.
JOHNSON: Exactly. And they see that person, you know, using government
JOHNSON: … to go to…
MATTHEWS: Well, let`s try to get ourselves in the head and the soul of Tom
Price. I don`t know the guy, but he might have gotten the idea he could
behave the way he does because he watches how the president behaves and his
CLARENCE PAGE, “CHICAGO TRIBUNE”: Following an example there. But you
know, funny thing about Tom Price is, you know, during the time of the
health care debate – this is his specialty, and he was out of the country
on another trip to what, about three cities over in Africa and Europe.
And Trump was saying, Where is he? Because Trump`s not going to go over to
Capitol Hill and start pushing for his own health care legislation.
MATTHEWS: He`d have to read it.
PAGE: Yes, he would have to read it. Heavens. We can`t have that.
PAGE: But this is what has been happening. There seems to be a
combination of, first, a shortage of personnel, a shortage of reverence for
the instructions that they`ve gotten as far as travel rules go.
But notice how the president is handling this. Even though he does have
extravagant travel of his own, he once again is pushing off the onus here
on his cabinet officer, and his base goes along with that. They will point
to Congress. They`ll point to the cabinet. They won`t point to President
Trump as being Republican for (INAUDIBLE)
MATTHEWS: Yes, when a plane has engine trouble, they start throwing chairs
out the door.
Anyway, Price isn`t the only Trump official who`s racked up questionable
expenses on travel. The Environmental Protection Agency`s Scott Pruitt and
Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin also are under scrutiny right now. And
according to reports today, so is interior secretary Ryan Zinke and
Veterans Affairs secretary David Schulkin.
According to Politico, Secretary Zinke`s travel with his staff includes a
$12,000 charter flight to take him to events in his hometown in Montana –
that`s convenient – and private flights between two Caribbean islands.
Anyway, VA secretary David Schulkin mixed his official business with
pleasure on a 10-day trip to Europe funded at least in part by the
government, according to “The Washington Post.” Quote, “He and his wife
spent about half their time sightseeing, including shopping and touring
We`re lucky to have Dan Diamond here of Politico. You guys are hot on the
trail. How deep does this go? How wide does it go, this misuse of federal
planes, government planes, misuse of private charter flights when you can
take a train ride to Philly. You can take the Amtrak, the Acela, splurge a
little. Put them in first class even. But chartering a plane is a bit
DIAMOND: I went to college in Philly, and I did that drive…
MATTHEWS: Where you go?
DIAMOND: I went to Patton (ph).
DIAMOND: And I did that driver over and over and over again. It`s only 90
minutes, two hours maybe down to Baltimore/D.C.
I think once you start pulling on this thread, Chris, it`s pretty clear the
controls have not been there across these different agencies. Whether
that`s because they shredded some of the career staff and they have these
positions still to fill, or the politicals who have come in just don`t have
the same reverence…
MATTHEWS: Well, wait a minute! I don`t want to cut you off. Whey didn`t
– didn`t he – didn`t Price call the White House and get an approval on
the use of these planes, these private planes?
DIAMOND: He got approval for the military flights overseas, but the jet up
to Nashville or San Diego, the White House said they didn`t know about that
and they would not have approved a domestic flight that cost $20,000.
MATTHEWS: Would they have approved the military flights, which cost
another half mill?
DIAMOND: They would. And that`s a different story.
MATTHEWS: Only one.
DIAMOND: Well, they say that it`s necessary for national security, for
MATTHEWS: Explain the national security, why the HHS secretary – he
doesn`t really command an army or a CIA or any kind of dangerous, exciting
agency – why he or she has to be flying in a federal plane, a military
DIAMOND: I cover HHS, so I think they`re exciting, and he does have the
surgeon general in his – in his army.
MATTHEWS: OK. Let me go to Peter Baker on this at “The Times.” Peter,
what do you think is the breadth of this story? Is this the first – is
this sort of the sacrificial lamb, they throw Price out the door? I mean,
he`s a doctor. He can go back and practice medicine, I assume. He can
find another career. Is this going to put the fire out or not?
BAKER: Yes, it`s a good question. I think as long as there are more
revelations, it`s going to keep the president angry and on the defensive.
So you might see other changes. Again, remember, Dr. Price – Mr. Price,
the secretary, had been in the bubble already…
MATTHEWS: He`s Dr. Price again. He`s Dr. Price again.
BAKER: He`s Dr. Price again. Exactly. And he`d been on the bubble
basically for other reasons. And this certainly pushed him over the edge.
But you know what? This is – This is dangerous to an administration. It
hurt President Bush 41 when his chief of staff was using a government
limousine to go to a stamp collection, you know, event, and when President
Clinton had an aide who took a helicopter to go golfing. These are things
that people remember, and they stick.
And it`s a lot more – it`s not a particularly deep story, but it`s a
memorable story and it`s the kind of thing that can hurt you politically.
MATTHEWS: Well, President Trump joked about firing Secretary Price if he
couldn`t get the votes on health care, something the White House continues
to struggle to do. Let`s watch the first threat to Mr. Price, Dr. Price.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
TRUMP: Secretary Tom Price is also here today. Dr. Price still lives the
Scout oath helping to keep millions of Americans strong and healthy as our
secretary of Health and Human Services. And he`s doing a great job. And
hopefully, he`s going to get the votes tomorrow to start our path toward
killing this horrible thing known as “Obama care” that`s really hurting us.
(CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
TRUMP: By the way, you going to get the votes? He better get them. He
better get them! Oh, he better – otherwise I`ll say, Tom, you`re fired!
I`ll get somebody.
(CHEERS AND APPLAUSE)
MATTHEWS: “Fredo, you broke my heart,” you know?
There he is, giving him the evil eye right there, Jenna. I mean, I`ve
never heard of a guy, like, threatens people with firing them as sort of a
PAGE: That kind of applause will do it!
MATTHEWS: I know. The people love – (INAUDIBLE) gladatorial, the Trump
people. They – you know, beat him up on the way out the door, you know,
take him – don`t – bang his head on the car window as you put him in the
car. I mean, they have – the Trump people are a gladatorial crowd.
JOHNSON: Yes. I mean, it reminds them of “The Apprentice,” which is what
Donald Trump was most well known for.
MATTHEWS: It reminds them of the Coliseum.
JOHNSON: Yes, but when it comes to…
JOHNSON: … actually firing people, the president really hasn`t been able
to pull the trigger on that.
MATTHEWS: Oh, really?
JOHNSON: He`s been waiting for people…
MATTHEWS: Have we got a list?
JOHNSON: Yes, there`s a long, long list.
MATTHEWS: Michael Flynn and head of national security and the press
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: They all quit. No one gets fired.
MATTHEWS: Oh, I see.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: They all resign.
MATTHEWS: Well, this guy did, technically.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes.
MATTHEWS: He technically put his resignation in early today, but we all
know he was fired. You can see the language. Trump said this afternoon,
I`ll decide tonight to fire him or not.
MATTHEWS: Right? He was fired, right?
DIAMOND: Essentially. They didn`t have a close relationship, too. I
think that played into the desire to see him out the door.
MATTHEWS: OK, let`s talk about where this goes further because I get the
feeling that they don`t have a clean theory of ethics in this White House.
Do they have someone who tells them what you`re supposed to do? Because if
they get their leadership from the top, they got a problem because Trump is
very unclear in the ethical department.
DIAMOND: Cabinet secretaries were briefed on taking military air abroad.
And Mick Mulvaney, the OMB chief, the budget director, today just sent out
a memorandum saying, Look, you`re here on behalf of taxpayers, and it`s up
to you to not only do what`s legal – because Price`s flights were legal –
but do what`s right.
And that reminder, whether it`s claiming Price – getting him out of the
White House or just the pressure that is now being brought to bear on the
rest of the cabinet seems to be pushing for transparency. Schulkin, the VA
secretary who`s under scrutiny – he put out this afternoon an e-mail
saying, Look, I haven`t taken any charter flights, and here is a new Web
site where you can track my travel and know if I took (INAUDIBLE) .
MATTHEWS: So he`s the one with the price on his head right now. He`s the
one that`s being looked at.
DIAMOND: I don`t think he`s the one at the top of the list. There`s a lot
MATTHEWS: Who`s at the top of the list right now in terms of trouble?
DIAMOND: I think probably Pruitt and…
MATTHEWS: … and Zinke.
Peter, do you know that? Is that what you think, those two guys are the
ones right now who are in the on-deck circle of ethical problems right now
BAKER: I mean, it`s possible. I mean, he likes both those cabinet
secretaries. He has other reasons to keep them in there.
You may also want to look at White House staff, you know, who`s been
managing the cabinet. We`re hearing that Rick Dearborn, the, you know,
deputy chief of staff, has earned the president`s ire this week. He also
is the one – one of the ones who urged the president to go down to Alabama
for the rally for Luther Strange. It turned out to blow up in the
president`s face. Mr. Trump is not happy about that, and Rick Dearborn I
think has gotten some of the president`s unhappiness directed at him as a
result. So you never know…
MATTHEWS: I think Robert Porter`s OK, isn`t he? Robert Porter OK?
BAKER: I think he`s OK, but today is Friday. Ask me again on Monday. You
never know. I mean, the truth is, I think in Trump`s orbit, it`s always a
game, right? It`s always a guessing game on who`s on, who`s up, who`s
down. And just because you`re on the outs with the president doesn`t
necessarily mean you`re going to be out. Jeff Sessions is still the
attorney general, and you know, H.R. McMaster is still the national
security adviser. For all the heat that each of them has taken, they`re
still on the job. So you can never tell for sure.
MATTHEWS: Peter, what`s the name of your book about Obama, the big coffee
table book you`ve done?
BAKER: It`s called “Obama: The Call of History.” But there`s another book
coming out this fall looking forward to – coming soon about…
BAKER: … Bobby Kennedy.
MATTHEWS: That is definitely coming. And I did not set that up. I was
trying to help you out, brother. Thank you. Your book`s beautiful on the
president. Anyway, thank you, Peter Baker. Thank you, Dan Diamond, Jenna
Johnson and Clarence Page.
Coming up – the ouster of Tom Price caps off a very bad week for the Trump
brand. What`s going to hurt Trump the most this week? Is it the bad tax
bill? Is it everything that`s going on in Puerto Rico? Everything, the
flyers – the high flyers in the cabinet living on the taxpayers` dime, the
failure to repeal “Obama care” again, his big loss down in Alabama when he
had his name on there, or maybe it`s his response to the devastation, as I
said, in Puerto Rico that could really sing – singe for a while?
The head of Homeland Security says the recovery effort down there, out in
Puerto Rico is a good news story. Really? Three and a half million people
without power, running water, food and money is a good news story? You`re
doing a great job, Brownie. The White House is already under fire for
their response to Hurricane Maria, and this isn`t going to help,
Plus, Steve Bannon`s beaten the president once this week. Now he`s looking
for more Republican scalps. Bannon wants to lead a breakaway party and he
has the war chest he needs to do it.
Finally, let me finish tonight with “Trump Watch.”
This is Friday. This is HARDBALL, where the action is.
MATTHEWS: Well, this evening`s ouster of Tom Price is just the latest hit
to the Trump brand. The president`s coming off a wave of losses this week,
from the failure to repeal “Obama care” to that major defeat down in
Alabama. We`re going to take a look at a very bad week for Donald Trump.
That`s coming up next.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
TRUMP: I don`t like to see that happen, and I think it`s a shame because
as a human being, Tom Price is a very good man, I can tell you.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL. That was President Trump talking
about HHS secretary Tom Price earlier today. Now that good man, as Trump
calls him, is out of a job after the firestorm over his expensive travel
And that caps off – it does – a week that`s not been good for President
Trump or his brand. The president started the week stirring up more
trouble than he counted on by taking on the NFL over player protests.
There was a major setback on his party`s plan to repeal “Obama care,`
another one. Senate leaders were forced to pull a planned vote due to lack
of support from Republicans. And now the defeat of his candidate, Luther
Strange, by conservative Roy Moore down in Alabama in that Republican
primary this Tuesday, leaving him 0 for 2 against his former chief
strategist, Steve Bannon.
And now even though Price is out, other members of his administration are
also now under scrutiny for their travel habits. All this as the
administration struggles with the recovery down in Puerto Rico.
But look at the picture, now with the acting homeland security secretary
calling the efforts there a “good news story.” Why would you say that?
For more, I`m joined by Ken Vogel of “The New York Times.” And Toluse
Olorunnipa is a White House reporter for Bloomberg.
Thank you, gentlemen.
Ken, I want to start with you at “The Times.”
We had your colleague Peter Baker on.
Let`s put it together in terms of a – sort of a time capsule of this week
in the presidency, the young presidency of Donald Trump. I mean, Tom
Price, NFL protests. The Cassidy fails on health care, no repeal there.
Trump loses with Strange. Bannon beats him. The official using jets. And
now the Puerto Rican absurdity of claiming it`s a good story.
Put it together.
KEN VOGEL, POLITICO: Yes, I mean, on at least a couple of those fronts,
things are only going to get worse.
The loss of Luther Strange in Alabama. Mitch McConnell is going to be
getting potentially another – at best, another Republican senator who is
not going to be willing to go along with him, making it that much harder to
pass big-ticket legislative items like health care or tax reform.
And then the situation in Puerto Rico obviously, very sadly, does not
appear to be getting better, and Trump has sort of put himself out there,
as have members of his Cabinet, in a way, vouching for the recovery effort
in a way that appears insensitive right now, and if things continue to get
worse, could look very bad in retrospect. Could be sort of the George W.
Bush “Heck of a job, Brownie” response to Katrina.
MATTHEWS: Yes. That`s what I thought.
Well, let me go to Toluse on this, because I – let`s start with the
beginning of the week, because it was a bad week.
I think Trump thought he would take on a football player or two, maybe a
group of them, and he would win because he`d have the fans on his side. He
would have the white players on his side. He would have the owners on his
It turns out he was trying to isolate these players who were militant in
their politics and wanted to make a statement. He ended up getting
TOLUSE OLORUNNIPA, BLOOMBERG NEWS: That`s exactly right.
And we have to remember that these protests were basically pretty small
events in 2017. It happened in 2016, when these protests started to gain
MATTHEWS: Taking a knee.
By 2017, you had maybe three or four players that were doing it. And
President Trump wanted to make a political issue out of this. He was
playing to the base down in Alabama, feeling like if he was able to get on
the same side as the flag, that he`d be able to play to his base, get more
people on his side, maybe get some of these football fans on his side.
But it turned out that a number of these players, owners, the NFL
commissioner all spoke out against him in a forceful and united event. And
this is something that sort of led into this sort of horrible week that the
president has had that makes you sort of remember the days of
infrastructure week, where they were…
MATTHEWS: Well, infrastructure.
MATTHEWS: You are laughing, Ken.
I think the statues can go either way in a couple of places like
battlefields. I think we`re going to end up keeping the statues at
Gettysburg, where the generals actually fought on both sides. That`s where
the statues belong, but – and some other places.
But I think this one really blew in his face – blew up in his face, the
football one. People love football. They love the players. They`re
heroes, these players. They root for them when they got the ball.
VOGEL: Yes. I actually think that it does play to his base.
MATTHEWS: Really? Tell me how.
VOGEL: Yes, because he is being – in this way, he`s being not politically
correct in taking on people and potentially calling out their First
Amendment right to protest.
But the fact he`s doing it in a way that his base perceives to be in
defense of patriotism plays right into that sort of positioning that he`s
already had and, as you suggested in the some of the Southern states, may
play to some of these latent racist sentiments that actually have served
him well, despite the fact that we don`t like to talk about them as
MATTHEWS: Yes, I will come down in a minute. I think, when you put your
fist in the air, that`s one thing. When you kneel down, I just don`t see
that as an act of aggression.
I think it`s a fairly recessive kind of act. It`s like, I can`t salute
this right now.
And, obviously, President Trump is trying to rally up his base at a time
when he knew during that rally in Alabama that there was a good chance that
his candidate would not win. His candidate ended up losing by about 10
points. So, this was a ploy to try to rally up his base and get them
OLORUNNIPA: Not so excited about private charter jets and military planes
and all of these expensive costs that his Cabinet…
MATTHEWS: Well, Toluse, I think – Toluse Olorunnipa. And I`m learning.
OLORUNNIPA: You got it.
MATTHEWS: Great name.
Ken Vogel. It`s so easy to Ken Vogel.
You know, Ken, I just think this week is going to end with people thinking
about Tom Price, and Trump was right to nip this one in the bud, if you
will, because I think it was the one people could understand.
When you get on an airplane, and you are back there, if you are lucky to be
on an airplane, and you`re back in 48-D, and there`s two heavyset people
around you, and you might get a cup of coffee two hours into the flight,
maybe, maybe, maybe, or some sort of snack, they call it, that nobody
wants, because it`s still left in the basket, you`re wondering, how does
this guy get to fly around, not only first-class, but on a chartered jet?
Anyway, they don`t like that stuff. And that`s the resentment that got
Trump elected. And he`s playing against that if he kept a guy like this
around. And there`s more of this coming.
Up next: The Trump administration has called the recovery effort in Puerto
Rico, as I said, a good-news story. But the mayor of San Juan has blasted
that. In an emotional press conference this afternoon, she said she`s
begging for help.
She`s tough. I like this mayor down there in San Juan.
This is HARDBALL, where the action is.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
ELAINE DUKE, ACTING HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY: I am very satisfied. I
know it`s a hard storm to recover from, but the amount of progress that`s
been made, and I really would appreciate any support that we get.
I know it is really a good-news story in terms of our ability to reach
people and the limited number of deaths that have taken place in such a
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: A really good-news story.
And welcome back to HARDBALL.
That was acting Homeland Secretary – Security Secretary Elaine Duke
calling the government`s response in Puerto Rico a good-news story.
But San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz has painted a very different picture.
Let`s listen to her.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
CARMEN YULIN CRUZ, MAYOR OF SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO: We are dying here. If
anybody out there is listening to us, we are dying, and you are killing us
with the inefficiency and the bureaucracy. We are going to see something
close to a genocide.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: Meanwhile, President Trump responded to the crisis today by
pointing out that the island is totally unable to handle the situation on
Let`s listen to the president.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We`re closely coordinated
with the territorial and local governments, which are totally and
unfortunately unable to handle this catastrophic crisis on their own, just
totally unable to.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: Totally unable to.
I`m joined right now by Gabe Gutierrez, who is in San Juan.
How does that sound out there, totally unable?
GABE GUTIERREZ, rMD-BO_NBC NEWS CORRESPONDENT: Hey there, Chris.
Well, you just played that press conference from San Juan`s mayor. She –
the anger just boiled over today. Up until now, she kind of had been
saying that FEMA had a lot of red tape. She kind of minced her words,
parsed her words a bit.
Local officials here up until today for the most part had been very careful
talking about the federal response, saying they appreciated the federal
response. The governor over and over again has said that the federal
government has delivered so far. He even said that in his news conference
this afternoon with the acting DHS secretary.
But San Juan`s today just sounded off, saying that this response was –
that that comment from the acting DHS secretary that this was a good-news
story seemed to set her off. And she said, repeated over and over that
people are dying here.
We didn`t speak with just her. We had a – spoke with a local
representative who was saying the same thing, very frustrated at the
federal response, Chris.
We have been talking about those shipping containers that have been in the
port for several days now, all this aid that isn`t getting to the right
Now, today, in a neighborhood outside San Juan, we saw that, yes, indeed,
some of that aid is trickling out, it is getting to some of the people, but
for many of them, it`s too little and it`s coming too slowly. Many people
are still desperate for food. They`re desperate for water.
There hasn`t been any power, there hasn`t been any communications systems.
And for them, hearing what the president said – and I will remind you,
Chris, many of them can`t actually hear what the president said. Their
telecommunications systems here are just decimated.
GUTIERREZ: But when you tell you – when you ask them, do they think the
federal response has been adequate, many of them will tell you they don`t
think it has.
That`s not everybody here, but there`s a growing frustration here among
some of these folks that say that they just haven`t seen the robust federal
response that you would see on the U.S. mainland. That`s the way they
MATTHEWS: Thanks for that sad report, NBC`s Gabe Gutierrez in San Juan.
I`m joined by actor Kamar de los Rose – de los Reyes, rather, who you may
know from “One Life to Live.” Of course, he`s on that program every day.
He just returned to Los Angeles after visiting a family in – his family in
Kamar, tell me about what you saw, what you feel, what you think about this
KAMAR DE LOS REYES, ACTOR: Well, the majority of what I saw was
It`s catastrophic there in Puerto Rico right now. And people are
desperate. There`s no active running water. There`s no power. There`s
shortages of food and fuel and lines to get all of that, lines that run
So, it`s dire there in Puerto Rico. And, just like the correspondent
before me said, people are dying. And just like the mayor – I echo the
mayor. People are dying, and we`re not hearing about it.
MATTHEWS: Is there someone – I guess my tendency is to think somebody
will come in, sort of a General MacArthur type and just bring order to the
thing. Is FEMA in charge? Is the governor in charge? Who is sort of
going around saying, where are the bottlenecks? What`s being held up?
What are the logistics? We will solve them.
Is there someone like that putting that together, or not?
DE LOS REYES: Well, it certainly doesn`t feel that way.
I`m not well-versed on, you know, on the politics and the bureaucracy of
this whole thing. I`m just one man, and I saw what I saw, and I experience
what I experienced. And I saw my family suffering. And I saw my friends
And I walked into supermarkets, and there was no water. And I stood in gas
lines for hours to get gas. And I stood in ATM lines for hours to get
cash. And then they ran out of cash.
DE LOS REYES: So I – you know, I don`t know what`s going on, but there`s
definitely a disconnect there, Chris.
MATTHEWS: It`s like it`s not even part of America. It`s like it`s…
DE LOS REYES: Correct.
MATTHEWS: Yes. Go ahead.
DE LOS REYES: And I also think that there`s a denial, a denial of the
deplorable nature of which this entire relief effort has been handled.
And Secretary Elaine Duke right now is – I know she`s backtracking, but
she obviously stuck her foot in her mouth. She`s trying to save face. And
she has put a lot of people at risk with her lack of action. And I
honestly believe she should consider resigning.
MATTHEWS: You know, I`m not usually a military person, but I sometimes
wish, in this situation, there was just someone down – like one of our
great generals, just to get down there and crap the whip, make these
bureaucrats get it moving. Get those ships unloaded. Get the truck
drivers back to work somehow. Get the stuff rolling.
It`s not like we`re a poor country. This…
DE LOS REYES: Yes.
MATTHEWS: … not a poor country.
DE LOS REYES: And why did it take, you know, eight days or nine days to
get 10,000 troops there?
DE LOS REYES: We – it took 48 hours to get 8,000 troops, boots on the
ground to Haiti in 2010, when the earthquake happened.
Why has it taken eight or nine days to get 10,000 troops to Puerto Rico, a
U.S. territory? We`re American citizens.
MATTHEWS: I know.
One thing you would expect Trump to be good at would be the kick-ass stuff.
And he`s not.
Thank you, Kamar de los Reyes.
DE LOS REYES: Thank you. Thank you for having me on, Chris. I really
MATTHEWS: Thank you for having a strong, strong, credible voice.
DE LOS REYES: Thank you.
MATTHEWS: Up next: Steve Bannon has just gotten started. He scored a big
win over the president in Alabama by knocking off the president`s candidate
down there. Is the next step a breakaway political party?
Is he going to break up the Republicans? I think he`s trying to. I think
I know it.
And this is HARDBALL, where the action is.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
STEVE BANNON, FORMER WHITE HOUSE CHIEF STRATEGIST: Last night, we talked
about starting a revolution with Judge Moore`s victory.
Well, Senator Corker stepped down today. He`s not going to run for
(CHEERING AND APPLAUSE)
BANNON: And you`re going to see in state after state after state people
that follow the model of Judge Moore, that do not need to raise money from
the elites, from the crony capitalists, from the fat cats in Washington,
D.C., New York City, Silicon Valley.
(CHEERING AND APPLAUSE)
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: Wow. That was – welcome back to HARDBALL.
Anyway, that was, of course, Steve Bannon, who looks like Steve Bannon, the
president`s former chief strategist, shortly after Roy Moore`s primary
victory down in Alabama.
“The New York Times” reporting that Bannon is now putting together a
political coalition designed to back other insurgent Republican candidates
similar to Moore all over the country.
He`s enlisted wealthy conservative mega-donors Robert and Rebekah Mercer to
help him pay for it. They have been in talks about creating a shadow party
since back in July.
Sources also tell “The New York Times” that: “Early plans call for the
creation of a sort of think tank to articulate the animating issues of the
coalition, and that the coalition will ally with existing groups on
specific issues and will support vetted candidates” – that`s a lot of
Latinate phrases – “and causes.”
Anyway, according to several reports, Bannon has already met with
prospective candidates who could challenge Republican incumbents.
They include Danny Tarkanian, who`s challenging Senator Dean Heller out in
Nevada, Chris McDaniel, potential challenger to Senator Roger Wicker in
Mississippi, and Kelli Ward, she`s a piece of work, who`s running against
Senator Jeff Flake in Arizona. She`s the one not being very kind to John
Roy Moore`s victory, by the way, has given Steve Bannon the green light to
wage a war against the establishment wing of the Republican Party but at
Let`s bring in the HARDBALL roundtable. Eliza Collins, Capitol Hill
reporter for “USA Today”, Kurt Bardella is president of Endeavor
Strategies, he`s a former “Breitbart” spokesman, and Seung Min Kim is a
congressional reporter for “Politico”.
Seung, you tell me this. Is this a breakaway movement to explode the
Republican Party or is he really trying to create a new faction, a new sort
of sub-unit of the Republican Party to challenge the Mitch McConnell types?
SEUNG MIN KIM, CONGRESSIONAL REPORTER, POLITICO: I think we`re going to
see how effective they are in the coming primaries. You have to remember
with Alabama, there were other factors in play with Senator Luther
Strange`s loss beyond the Bannon influence in the Trump –
MATTHEWS: Like what?
KIM: His involvement with the disgraced former Governor Bentley. He was
the attorney general at the time when he sort of informed the legislators
in Montgomery to basically stop their impeachment process and mysteriously
later appointed to Jeff Sessions` Senate seat.
KIM: And I`ve talked to people in Alabama. I was down there in August
before the first round of voting. A lot of people said that at the end of
the day may have had a much bigger impact –
MATTHEWS: Do you think his name was a turnoff? Kurt, what do you think?
KIM: It was a little strange.
KURT BARDELLA, FORMER BREITBART SPOKESMAN: Strange, a little strange.
MATTHEWS: Everybody has a name, but I just thought Strange –
BARDELLA: Moore or Strange.
MATTHEWS: This guy is eerie.
Let`s get serious. I look at Bannon. Here`s a guy that looks like Bannon.
Bannon looks like he is. He`s got that expression on his face. He`s very
militant. He`s angry all the time.
Look at him. He never puts a coat and tie on. He`s got this sort of
revolutionary fatigue on there, ready to go like Castro or something. Look
He just looks like – he`s like Michael Moore from the right. He`s very
much like that. No, look at him. It`s all tough guy stuff.
Look at him. Look at the way he holds the mike. Everything is tough guy.
What does he want to do, just beat up Mitch McConnell?
BARDELLA: Yes. He wants, he – I`m sorry, he has said he wants to blow up
the Republican Party, the establishment party. He tried this back in 2014.
MATTHEWS: For what? Why?
BARDELLA: Because he hates anything that has anything to do – because
they rejected him. I mean, that`s part of it. I think a lot of this from
Steve Bannon and a lot of ways from Donald Trump, too, stems from being
rejected by the establishment class and they want to get back at him.
ELIZA COLLINS, CAPITOL HILL REPORTER, USA TODAY: He wants to replace them
with people that have what Trump ran on, whether or not Trump is the top of
the party, I don`t think is the issue. They want strong on immigration.
MATTHEWS: You mean strong against immigration.
COLLINS: Strong against immigration. Yes. They want the wall. They want
anti-trade. You know, they want –
MATTHEWS: So, it`s nationalism.
MATTHEWS: In the crudest form.
COLLINS: It`s not the Republican Party that Mitch McConnell represents.
MATTHEWS: You think it would be interesting if they would at least adapt
some of the stuff I like starting with, well, how about the stupid wars.
Why don`t they take on Trump for re-activating the war in Afghanistan which
is what Trump ran against stupid wars, that`s he`s now going to continue in
KIM: Exactly, and you`ve seen – especially what the president`s
announcement regarding Afghanistan last month. That`s again something that
MATTHEWS: Is Bannon going to fight that?
KIM: Doesn`t seem like it so far.
KIM: If you look at – I mean, if you look at Breitbart and what they are
focused on, it is those issues of trade and immigration that really jazz up
the conservative base.
KIM: And that`s what you`ll see continue in these other primaries going
on. I mean, look at Kelli Ward in Arizona. Jeff Flake is going to be the
perfect test case of that because Flake has been that classic let`s reform
the immigration system.
MATTHEWS: Kelli Ward, I have – she`s leading Jeff Flake in the polls,
Kurt – I don`t understand this. She said John McCain should quit because
he`s in bad health and should get out of the way. That`s pretty rough.
BARDELLA: Bannon and Breitbart world –
MATTHEWS: So she can have the job. I`m sorry.
MATTHEWS: She wants him to go away, leave the seat so she can be the
senator even though she`s never been elected.
BARDELLA: A lot of self-interest at play. But for a lot of these people -
- again, Bannon and Breitbart believe the voters are so angry with anyone
with the word incumbent in Washington next to them that they can easily say
MATTHEWS: Well, I guess the tricky part is Steve Bannon is not to have a
job so you can`t be an incumbent, right?
COLLINS: Right, you can`t be an incumbent.
MATTHEWS: It`s amazing that you can make a living doing this. Have you
noticed that? How do they all get paid these guys? Is this family? The -
BARDELLA: Oh, you have the Mercers. I mean –
KIM: They are going to fund these.
BARDELLA: Bannon is a lot –
MATTHEWS: Follow the money.
BARDELLA: He`s got a bank roll.
MATTHEWS: Let`s follow what those people want.
Anyway, the round table is sticking with us. Next, these three will tell
me something I don`t know. Hopefully something you`ll be talking about all
weekend because you heard it here, right? I`m raising the bar.
This is HARDBALL, where the action is.
MATTHEWS: Well, it`s Friday night. We`re back with the roundtable.
Eliza, dazzle us with something we`ll talk about all weekend. What is it?
COLLINS: So, it`s not just the anti-establishment Republicans that are
upset with Mitch McConnell I think most recently because of failure to pass
Obamacare. Yesterday, I was talking to Rep Mark Walker, head of the
Republican Study Committee, which is conservative but not hard line. And
he said this is the eighth or ninth inning of strikes against McConnell,
and he`s going to leave it up to the Senate if he should step down. But he
MATTHEWS: They don`t like him?
COLLINS: He didn`t say he should stay.
MATTHEWS: Well, we`ll see.
BARDELLA: You know, during the Obama administration, Republicans in
Congress issued more than 100 subpoenas for discovery against the
administration. This year, less than five from Republicans in the
MATTHEWS: Whoa. They are being nice.
BARDELLA: Very nice.
MATTHEWS: I thought –
BARDELLA: We weren`t that nice when I was there.
KIM: So, remember the name Michael Grimm. Before we had –
MATTHEWS: Oh, the guy who was going to beat up that guy, break him –
break him like a boy –
KIM: Yes, before we had a lawmaker threatening to body slam reporters and
admin officials throwing reporters out of meetings and threatening to
arrest us, Michael Grimm was the congressman who threatened to throw a
reporter over the balcony at the Capitol, ended time in prison, federal
prison for tax fraud, but he`s out. And he`s announcing that he`s running
for Congress again tomorrow.
MATTHEWS: Against Dan Donavan.
MATTHEWS: I think I`m for Donovan. I hope he doesn`t hurt him up there.
Anyway, Eliza Collins, Kurt Bardella and Seung Min Kim, thank you.
Up next, “The Washington Post`s” Sally Quinn, the Sally Quinn, is coming
here. She`s got a new memoir out and it touches on everything from
marriage to her use of hexes against people who did her wrong.
You`re watching HARDBALL.
MATTHEWS: Welcome back to HARDBALL.
When people think about Washington, D.C., spirituality isn`t the first word
that comes to their mind. In a new book, however, “Finding Magic: A
Spiritual Memoir,” journalist Sally Quinn explores what the word faith
means to her while describing what it`s been like to live in Washington,
D.C. throughout Watergate, Vietnam, and 9/11.
She writes: Washington is all about power, and seeking power, often makes
people, even good people, do bad things. That`s from most of my adult life
in Washington, of course, watching those seeking power, getting and losing
it, using and abusing.
That`s Sally Quinn talking. Not me.
I`m joined right now by herself, Sally Quinn has always one of the most
frightening people in Washington.
Glamorous, yes, I`ll give you that. But when you wrote for “The Washington
Post”, when you went after like Steve Martindale, Hamilton Jordan, they
died. I used to read it on the bus, these gigantic takeout pieces in “The
Washington Post” when your husband was running the paper, which is a hugely
successful paper, “The Washington Post”, it crackled with excitement.
And now, you write a book where you say, if you think I was scary as a
reporter, I can put a hex on you. Talk about the spiritual power of
wishing someone to die. How does that work?
SALLY QUINN, AUTHOR, “FINDING MAGIC: A SPIRITUAL MEMOIR”: Well, let me
just say –
MATTHEWS: No, no, you have it here, you can`t run away from it.
QUINN: I`m not. Listen –
MATTHEWS: This is a book you`ve got to read because it`s the only book
I`ve read about D.C. and spiritual power that comes alive with a really
smart person with strong focus.
QUINN: Yes. Well, I did in my youth, because I was raised in Savannah,
Georgia, in Statesboro, Georgia, by Presbyterian Scots who believed in the
standing stones and time travel and voodoo and the occult and ghost and
psychic phenomenon and astrology and tarot cards. So, I was raised – that
was what I call my embedded religion.
MATTHEWS: Does it work?
QUINN: Well, I don`t know whether it works or not.
MATTHEWS: But you knocked off a couple of people with hexes.
QUINN: I did put hexes on people, but you can also call it spells or
prayers or wishes. I didn`t wish them to be knocked off. I wish them only
to suffer what they had caused me to suffer.
MATTHEWS: Yes, so it`s justice here?
QUINN: Yes. I mean, so, if you`re in Washington, for instance, look at
how many people wish other people ill in Washington, D.C.
MATTHEWS: I agree with that.
QUINN: And I cannot tell you how many people, my friends, who don`t
believe in this, have begged me to put a hex on Donald Trump.
MATTHEWS: Yes, you know, when –
QUINN: And I don`t do it anymore. I`m not doing it. It`s over.
MATTHEWS: You know, I knew something – one of my producers, she said n
Washington, no one`s late for an execution. There`s a schadenfreude in
this town. When somebody goes down like Tom Price, there`s a sort of, it
ain`t me. I`m lucky, it didn`t kill me.
Let`s talk about your husband who we both liked. I mean, you loved him.
You were married to probably the greatest journalist in Washington in
modern history, the editor of “The Washington Post” who brought down Nixon,
did the Pentagon papers, all this incredibly gutsy stuff. And every single
person wanted Ben to respect him. What I always wanted was Ben to look at
me and say, you`re great, Chris. You`re great.
QUINN: He loved you. He said you were great. He loved you. You made him
MATTHEWS: OK, well, here`s the story. You`re married to Ben.
QUINN: And he also admired you because of the books that you wrote and he
thought you were a great American.
MATTHEWS: When I did my last book on Jack Kennedy, when I did that book
and you had that wonderful party, I got there early at Georgetown, and Ben
was sitting there and I could tell there was something wrong. And you knew
about it and you kept it, and you protected this great man who was
suffering from dementia. He was so charming and good looking, to put it
MATTHEWS: All that may be true from your perspective and, well, it should
be. But Ben Bradley was such a guy that I didn`t recognize, but I did
notice he was reading my book and he was like puzzling.
MATTHEWS: When did that start, this beautiful couple of yours, when did
you realize that he had a problem?
QUINN: Well, he was diagnosed eight years before he died. But I got him
diagnosed because he started turning against me. He started becoming
MATTHEWS: You write that.
QUINN: And we had a fabulous marriage. I mean, we were really in love
with each other.
MATTHEWS: That comes with dementia. That`s classic.
QUINN: But I didn`t know that. So we went to a shrink and I would say to
shrink, my God, he`s saying these awful things to me. And he would say, I
never said that, I love you, why would I talk to you that way? And I
thought he was gas-lighting me.
And then he was diagnosed, because he was getting very forgetful, then I
read about it and saw the classic thing.
QUINN: Particularly the person they love –
MATTHEWS: I mean, you loved him so much, but the great story – there`s
three or four great stories here. First of all, you`re frightening
QUINN: Only three or four?
MATTHEWS: Well, I`m going to tell you some of the big stuff, because if
I`m going to read this book, the parts I like to read, what I liked, the
hexes of course. How could I not like the fact that you knocked off some
people just by wishing them evil, which is really a great story about
Washington, because there`s so much of this town. You actually succeeded.
And the other thing is about your love for the guy we all admired. And you
were the social arbitrix of this town. You decided who was in and who was
MATTHEWS: OK. Sally Quinn, who decides who`s in and who`s out in
Washington, her new book, “Finding Magic,” it really is about spirituality
of a kind I felt in the Peace Corps, which was it wasn`t going to church
spiritualism, it was a feeling of really happy connection to your world
you`re living in.
And I know what you meant. I know what you mean by this spiritual thing
that you write about. It`s lower case Christian.
QUINN: Yes. It`s Christianity with a C.
MATTHEWS: The lower case, it`s just really good. And I think she`s a
great person with a hell of a story here, and really a great read.
QUINN: Thank you.
MATTHEWS: She`s a great writer. Most importantly that.
We return – when I come back, I want to talk about the Trump watch
tonight, this Friday night.
QUINN: I just want to say one thing, Washington is a spiritual hardship
post, and that`s what people should know.
MATTHEWS: Thank you. We do have the Lincoln Memorial.
You`re watching HARDBALL.
MATTHEWS: “Trump Watch” Friday, September 29th, 2017.
I`ve noticed here in Washington that no one is ever late for a hanging.
There`s a zest that comes from late-breaking news, to someone has gotten
the axe, someone else that is, someone not you. It`s called in German
schadenfreude, a joy to other`s tragedy, and yes, it is fairly grotesque.
Why would anyone get a kick out of someone getting brought down, knocked
out of their job, shoved into humiliation by the sometimes unpredictable
shifting standards in this city. The fact is nothing and therefore no one
is all that secure here, especially in Trump`s Washington. And that
applies to the people working for him most of all. When you come roaring
into town like Oliver Cromwell looking for witches to burn and condemning
the establishment, you have to expect some blowback.
Tom Price was supposed to repeal Obamacare. Instead, he got repealed. The
Trump family has allowed the oligarchs to reign freely and ride
expensively. Meanwhile, they`ve behaved themselves like the Romanovs.
That`s HARDBALL for now. Thanks for being with us.
“ALL IN WITH CHRIS HAYES” starts right now.
THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY
Copy: Content and programming copyright 2017 MSNBC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Copyright 2017 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are
protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced,
distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the
prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter
or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the