The Rachel Maddow Show Weekdays at 9PM


... more Duration: {{video.duration.momentjs}}

Rachel Maddow StoriesRSS

select from:

E.g., 3/21/2018
E.g., 3/21/2018
Steve Scalise

GOP leader flunks test on separation of church and state

02/12/18 11:00AM

House Majority Whip Steve Scalise (R-La.) delivered the keynote address at the National Prayer Breakfast in D.C. last week, and devoted much of his remarks to his recovery from last year's shooting that nearly killed him. It was his faith, the Republican said, that helped him persevere.

But Scalise ran into a little trouble when he decided to share some thoughts on American history.

"This was a nation founded with a deep belief in God. Our founding fathers talked about it when they were preparing to draft the Constitution. In fact, Thomas Jefferson -- who was the author of the Constitution -- if you go to the Jefferson Memorial right now, go read this inscription from Thomas Jefferson: 'God who gave us life gave us liberty. Can the liberties of a nation be secure when we have removed a conviction that these liberties are the gift of God?'

"You can't separate church from state.... People would say, you know, when you're voting on issues, how do you separate your faith from the way you vote? Faith is part of who you are."

OK, there's a lot to unpack here, so let's take this one step at a time.

We know that despite Scalise's claim, Thomas Jefferson didn't write the Constitution. He was actually in France at the time the Constitution was crafted. Jefferson did write the Declaration of Independence a decade earlier, but that isn't the same thing. (That's not to say Jefferson was irrelevant -- his Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom likely helped influence the drafting of the First Amendment -- but to say Jefferson was the Constitution's "author" is plainly wrong. That title largely belongs to James Madison, who, incidentally, also championed the separation of church and state.)

We also know that while Jefferson's approach to religion was complex -- see the Jefferson Bible, for example -- his approach to religious liberty was straightforward: he was an ardent champion of church-state separation. It's what makes Scalise's reliance on Jefferson to argue against the principle so spectacularly wrong.

read more

Image: Rep. Devin Nunes Briefs Press On House Intelligence Cmte Russia Investigation

Already flailing, Devin Nunes gets into the propaganda game

02/12/18 10:00AM

Last year, a new website called The Free Telegraph launched, offering visitors Republican-friendly online news. What visitors probably didn't realize was the online venture didn't just look like partisan propaganda; it was quite literally partisan propaganda: the site was the creation of the Republican Governors Association.

When the Associated Press inquired about this, the RGA added a disclosure notice about who was paying for the content -- the notice was put in a small, gray font, at the bottom of the page, against a gray background -- though the Republicans responsible for the site have since removed that language. Those who visit the outlet, designed to look like an online news website, have no way of knowing that the stories are paid Republican content.

There's a lot of this going around. For example, the Maine Examiner looks like a state-based news website, and purports to be a project of "a small group of Mainers who simply publish Maine news, trends, and interesting pieces about you, the people of Maine." Its critics have made a compelling case, however, that the site appears to be "working in conjunction with the state Republican Party."

According to a report in Politico, a leading House Republican appears to be playing the same game.

House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes, a relentless critic of the media, has found a way around the often unflattering coverage of his role in the Trump-Russia investigation -- by operating his own partisan news outlet.

Resembling a local, conservative news site, "The California Republican" is classified on Facebook as a "media/news company" and claims to deliver "the best of US, California, and Central Valley news, sports, and analysis."

One recent item from the California Republican's Twitter feed featured a photograph of Nunes beneath text that read, "This is what a hero looks like." How subtle.

Though the website now appears to be off-line, there was an easy-to-miss disclosure notice at the bottom of the home page -- in a small, gray font against a black background -- letting eagle-eyed visitors know that the site is "paid for by the Devin Nunes Campaign Committee."

Why should you care? Because when politicians and their campaign operations get into the propaganda business, no one benefits.

read more

Pennsylvania State Senate

Pennsylvania GOP takes gerrymandering in an unfortunate direction

02/12/18 09:30AM

It's not easy to choose the nation's most outrageous example of congressional gerrymandering, but Pennsylvania has to be among the most ridiculous.

After the 2010 census, the state legislature's Republican majority took an evenly divided state, drew up 18 congressional districts, and put 13 of them in safely GOP hands. The result was tough to defend: in 2012, for example, Democratic congressional candidates received 51% of the vote in Pennsylvania, but only 28% of the power.

The state Supreme Court rejected the current map last month, saying it "clearly, plainly, and palpably" violated the Pennsylvania Constitution. The ruling added that the Republicans' gerrymandering has had "corrosive effects on our entire democratic process through the deliberate dilution of our citizenry's individual votes."

GOP state legislators didn't take this well -- they tried to get the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene, and when that failed, they threatened to impeach the state Supreme Court justices who ruled against their gerrymandered map -- but the process is moving forward.

It's just not moving forward in an especially constructive direction.

On Friday, Republican leaders in the legislature submitted their new map for the governor's approval.... Unfortunately for Pennsylvania voters, the new districts show just as much partisan bias as the old ones. [...]

From a partisan standpoint, in other words, the new map is almost exactly like the old one.

The Washington Post's analysis noted that Donald Trump out-performed Hillary Clinton in 12 out of Pennsylvania's 18 districts. Under the newly submitted Republican alternative, Trump would also receive more votes in 12 districts -- by "virtually identical" margins.

read more


'Dysfunction' starts to overcome Kelly's White House

02/12/18 09:00AM

The early months of Donald Trump's presidency featured constant turmoil in the White House. On a near-daily basis, Americans were confronted with reports of chaos, in-fighting, distrust, and behind-the-scenes leaks intended to boost one faction over another.

More than a few observers started comparing Trump's out-of-control West Wing to "Game of Thrones." When the president held a press conference one year ago this week and described his team as a "fine-tuned machine," nearly everyone immediately found it hilarious because the assessment was so badly at odds with reality.

When John Kelly made the transition from four-star general to Homeland Security secretary to White House chief of staff, the mayhem was supposed to end. Instead, Trump World now appears to have come full circle. The Washington Post put it this way:

Aides described a resulting level of dysfunction not experienced behind the scenes at the White House since the early months of Trump’s presidency. Dormant ­rivalries have come alive, with suspicions swirling about some of the most senior officials and the roles they apparently played in protecting [former White House Staff Secretary Rob] Porter.

Two prominent White House staffers were forced to resign last week following allegations of violent domestic abuse -- part of a recent trend in which the administration has begun hemorrhaging staff. Aides have started to tell reporters that Kelly's version of events surrounding Porter's exit wasn't true. Communications Director Hope Hicks is under  fire in ways she's not accustomed to. Kelly has reportedly made clear that he's willing to resign.

For his part, Trump has not only vented his frustrations about Kelly's performance, he's also begun "speculating about potential replacements," and a short list of possible successors has apparently emerged.

By one account, Trump last week privately confided in, of all people, Reince Priebus -- the man he ousted as chief of staff to install Kelly.

read more

Image: Devin Nunes, Eric Swalwell, Jim Himes

Trump clears bogus Republican memo, but blocks Dems' rebuttal

02/12/18 08:30AM

Around 1 p.m. (ET) on Friday, a reporter asked Donald Trump if he'd release the Democratic response to the Republicans' discredited "Nunes memo." The president didn't hesitate. "Yes," he replied. "It's going to be released soon."

By Friday evening, that was no longer true.

Citing national security concerns, the White House on Friday formally notified the House intelligence committee that President Donald Trump is "unable" to declassify a memo drafted by Democrats that counters GOP allegations about abuse of government surveillance powers in the FBI's Russia probe.

White House counsel Don McGahn said in a letter to the committee that the memo contains "numerous properly classified and especially sensitive passages" and asked the intelligence panel to revise the memo with the help of the Justice Department. He said Trump is still "inclined" to release the memo in the interest of transparency if revisions are made.

Trump himself weighed in via Twitter, complaining that the Democratic document was "political and long" -- remember, he's not much of a reader -- and designed specifically to be rejected.

In a missive the president almost certainly didn't write himself, the tweet added that the memo's Democratic authors knew it "would have to be heavily redacted, whereupon they would blame the White House for lack of transparency."

Raise your hand if you believe Donald Trump personally wrote a tweet featuring the word "whereupon."

read more

Image: Donald Trump

Trump apparently has no use for the #MeToo movement

02/12/18 08:00AM

As the national conversation about sexual misconduct continues to unfold, and the backlash against those facing abuse allegations intensifies, Donald Trump now seems eager to take a side.

On Friday, for example, the president was asked about former White House Staff Secretary Rob Porter, who resigned following reports of his alleged abuse toward both of his ex-wives. Instead of denouncing domestic abuse, Trump highlighted what he saw as the most important elements of the Porter scandal: the former aide "worked very hard," did "a very good job," and is "very sad."

Hours later, another White House staffer, speechwriter David Sorensen, also resigned following claims from his ex-wife that he was violent and emotionally abusive. Sorensen denies the allegations.

It's against this backdrop that the president decided over the weekend to shed additional light on his views on recent developments, effectively offering a rejoinder to the #MeToo movement:

"Peoples lives are being shattered and destroyed by a mere allegation. Some are true and some are false. Some are old and some are new. There is no recovery for someone falsely accused -- life and career are gone. Is there no such thing any longer as Due Process?"

There are some important problems with the president's perspective. Trump may believe, for example, that those accused of misconduct can never recover, but he appears to be living proof to the contrary: despite the fact that he personally has faced allegations from a wide variety of women, Trump was nevertheless elected president.

For that matter, do you know what else often "shatters and destroys" people's lives? Being the target of sexual misconduct and abuse. It's the part of the equation about which Trump has very little to say.

But perhaps the most striking part of the president's message was his sudden interest in "due process."

read more

A nurse prepares a flu shot at the Salvation Army in Atlanta, Wednesday, Feb. 7, 2018.

This Week in God, 2.10.18

02/10/18 08:00AM

First up from the God Machine this week is a stunning comment from an evangelical minister who apparently believes Christianity immunizes people from the flu. Politico reported this week:

Texas minister Gloria Copeland, who sat on the Trump campaign's evangelical executive advisory board, denied the country is in the midst of a severe flu outbreak in a Facebook video that went viral because, "Jesus himself is our flu shot. He redeemed us from the curse of the flu."

"We have a duck season, a deer season, but we don't have a flu season and don't receive it when someone threatens you with 'everybody is getting the flu,'" Copeland added. "We've already had our shot: He bore our sicknesses and carried our diseases. That's what we stand on. And by his stripes we are healed."

Right off the bat, let's note that public-health officials would probably discourage people from relying on supernatural treatments in response to virus outbreaks, and that Copeland's comments during an especially brutal flu season were irresponsible.

Making matters slightly worse, Right Wing Watch explained that Copeland's Texas megachurch was at the center of a measles outbreak in 2013 "that was attributed to the church’s belief that congregants can forego vaccines because Jesus will protect them from illness." In other words, Copeland probably ought to know better.

But perhaps most striking from a political perspective is that Copeland isn't just some fringe figure with no influence among those in power. On the contrary, Copeland and her husband, Kenneth Copeland, both served as members of Donald Trump's evangelical advisory panel in 2016, alongside the likes of Michele Bachmann, Ralph Reed, James Dobson, Robert Jeffress, and Jerry Falwell, Jr.

For the record, it's not too late to get a flu shot if you haven't already had one.

Also from the God Machine this week:

read more

Friday's Mini-Report, 2.9.18

02/09/18 05:30PM

Today's edition of quick hits:

* Huge news breaking at the Justice Department: "Rachel L. Brand, the No. 3 official at the Justice Department, plans to step down after nine months on the job as the country's top law enforcement agency has been under attack by President Trump, according to two people briefed on her decision."

* White House scuttlebutt: "John F. Kelly, the White House chief of staff, told officials in the West Wing on Friday that he was willing to step down over his handling of allegations of spousal abuse against Rob Porter, the staff secretary who resigned in disgrace this week over the accusations, according to two officials aware of the discussions."

* On a related note: "President Donald Trump, frustrated by his staff's handling of the abuse allegations against Rob Porter, is increasingly venting about Chief of Staff John Kelly and speculating about potential replacements, according to multiple sources familiar with the matter."

* This guy: "House lawmakers celebrated themselves this week for passing a bill that cracks down on sexual harassers in Congress. But they have an alleged harasser in their midst who is trying to quietly slip by: Rep. Blake Farenthold (R-Texas)."

* Hmm: "The FBI was monitoring Carter Page when the former Trump campaign adviser says he spoke with Trump adviser Steve Bannon about Russia in January 2017, raising the strong possibility that the FBI intercepted a conversation between the two men."

* Devin Nunes: "Last month, an attorney expressed his outrage with leaders of the House Intelligence Committee: He demanded to know why a committee official shared his client's secret testimony with another lawyer, a blatant violation of the panel's rules."

* A sensible choice: "Ethics experts were over the moon with President Donald Trump's selection to lead the Office of Government Ethics, Emory Rounds."

* Speaking of executive-branch picks: "President Trump's nominee to lead the Internal Revenue Service is a longtime tax lawyer who has specialized in defending people and companies against the tax agency in court."

read more


About The Rachel Maddow Show

Launched in 2008, “The Rachel Maddow Show” follows the machinations of policy making in America, from local political activism to international diplomacy. Rachel Maddow looks past the distractions of political theater and stunts and focuses on the legislative proposals and policies that shape American life - as well as the people making and influencing those policies and their ultimate outcome, intended or otherwise.


Latest Book