A statue of the United States first President, George Washington, is seen under the Capitol dome in Washington January 2, 2013. The new 113th U.S. Congress...
GARY CAMERON

With vote to protect Dreamers, Dems discredit key GOP attack

Updated

The Rachel Maddow Show, 6/4/19, 9:00 PM ET

Democrats unanimous in passing bill to protect Dreamers

Rachel Maddow reports on the House passage of the American Dream and Promise Act of 2019 with the votes of every Democrat and seven Republicans.
Rachel Maddow reports on the House passage of the American Dream and Promise Act of 2019 with the votes of every Democrat and seven Republicans.
The House yesterday took up an expanded version of the decade-old Dream Act – it’s now called the “Dream and Promise Act” – and proponents had reason to cheer when the gavel came down.

The House-passed bill would protect from deportation and provide a pathway toward citizenship for young migrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children. Many would-be “Dreamers” currently safeguarded by the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA, which only the federal courts have thwarted Trump from dismantling.

It would also shield others here temporarily because their home countries — chiefly in Central America, Africa and the Middle East — have been ravaged by wars or natural disasters.

The bill passed 237 to 187, with unanimous Democratic support, and the backing of seven House Republicans. Nine years earlier, when the chamber took up the original Dream Act, three dozen conservative House Dems balked, while eight GOP members voted for it.

All of which suggests that Democrats have grown more unified and progressive on the issue, while Republicans’ hostility toward the mainstream proposal has managed to get slightly more intense. (The official House GOP Twitter account condemned the proposal yesterday as a “mass amnesty bill.”)

After the 2010 bill passed, it died in the Senate at the hands of a Republican filibuster. This year, the filibuster probably won’t matter, because Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) is unlikely to allow the chamber to consider the bill at all.

It’s against this backdrop that GOP leaders, including Donald Trump, are pushing a disjointed message: Republicans are asking the public to believe the bills Democrats keep passing are misguided, while simultaneously arguing that Democrats aren’t passing any bills.

Indeed, the president has been almost hysterical on this point, tweeting before leaving for the U.K., “[T]he Dems are getting nothing done in Congress. They are frozen stiff.” It came on the heels of a series of related missives, one of which insisted, “Democrats … don’t want to do anything.”

His allies have been quick to echo the talking points. Senate Homeland Security Committee Chairman Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) argued last week, “It’s going to be pretty hard to pass legislation when that’s all the House is really doing [focusing on investigating White House scandals]. I warned voters ahead of the 2018 election that if you put Democrats in front of the House, all you’re going to be talking about is investigations, talk of impeachment and it won’t be about governing.”

The evidence proving these claims wrong is hard to miss.

In every Congress, the House majority leadership, regardless of which party is in control, sets aside the first 10 available bill numbers. As regular readers know, it’s intended as a symbolic way to signal a party’s top legislative priorities: H.R. 1 through H.R. 10 will reflect the leadership’s most important goals.

We haven’t yet reached the half-way point of the first year of this Congress, and already the House Democratic majority has passed its democracy-reform package (H.R. 1), the Equality Act to expand civil rights to LGBTQ Americans (H.R. 5), the Dream and Promise Act (H.R. 6), the Paycheck Fairness Act to address pay disparities between men and women (H.R. 7), a bill to expand background checks on gun purchases (H.R. 8), and a bill to address the climate crisis (H.R. 9).

House Dems have also passed a bill to lower prescription drug costs, a couple of other health care bills, and an expansion of the Violence Against Women Act.

On the other side of Capitol Hill, the list of major legislative breakthroughs in the Republican-led Senate is effectively blank. By some measures, the Senate GOP’s leadership has effectively given up on legislating altogether.

One of Trump’s principal political goals in recent months has been to make the case that lawmakers can’t walk and chew gum at the same time: Congress can either focus on governing or they can scrutinize his many scandals. To try to do both, the White House has said, “can’t work.”

Reality is telling a very different story. Democrats can credibly claim they’re focused on governing and oversight. Can Republicans say the same?