Speaker of the House John Boehner leaves the House Republican Conference meeting in the basement of the Capitol to speak to the media on Friday, Oct. 4, 2013.
Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call/Getty Images

The worst debt-ceiling talking point of them all

Updated

Once we brush past shallow rhetoric about “negotiations,” the Republican line on the debt ceiling boils down to this: other presidents have paid a ransom to avoid catastrophic economic consequences, so President Obama should, too.

The talking point – which GOP pollsters hadn’t formulated during the Republicans’ first debt-ceiling crisis in 2011 – may even sound fairly reasonable, at least at first blush, for those who don’t know better. It also makes it seem as if GOP lawmakers are doing something routine when they threaten to hurt Americans on purpose. If it’s happened before, the argument goes, then folks like me are wrong to use words like “unprecedented.”

Here was House Speaker John Boehner’s (R-Ohio) pitch yesterday:

“Listen, the debt limit is right around the corner. The president is saying, ‘I won’t negotiate. I won’t have a conversation.’ Even though, President Reagan negotiated with Democrats who controlled the Congress back then. Even though President George Herbert Walker Bush had a conversation about raising the debt limit. During the Clinton administration, there were three fights over the debt limit. You and I participated in several of those. And even President Obama himself in 2011, went through a negotiation.

“Now, he’s saying., ‘No. I’m not going to do this.’ I’m going to tell you what, George. The nation’s credit is at risk because of the administration’s refusal to sit down and have a conversation.”

This has quickly become the key arrow in the GOP’s quiver, serving as the basis for weekly addressesop-eds, and countless media interviews. The ubiquitous argument has two main prongs: (1) other presidents have negotiated over the debt ceiling; and (2) debt-ceiling negotiations routinely lead to debt-reduction agreements.

Not surprisingly, the argument is wildly misleading, but given the severity of the crisis and the talking point’s importance to Republicans, it’s probably worth considering in detail.

First, a little common sense is in order. The right would have us believe that debt-ceiling increases and debt-reduction agreements simply go together – they’re the chocolate and peanut butter of U.S. fiscal policy. But even casual observers might notice an obvious flaw: the debt ceiling has been raised about 90 times over eight decades, and there haven’t been 90 debt-reduction agreements over that period. So just on a surface level, we know there’s a serious flaw in the argument.

Second, and more important, are the details Republicans choose to overlook. For example, since President Reagan, Congress has approved 45 debt-ceiling increases. How many of them were tied to budget deals? Seven. In other words, over the last several decades, 38 out of 45 debt-ceiling increases were not part of debt-reduction agreements (or any other policymaking measures).

Indeed, we should highlight an inconvenient detail: many leading Republican members of Congress, including a cast of characters that includes John Boehner, Eric Cantor, and Mitch McConnell, have each voted for clean debt-ceiling increases unrelated to budget deals.

And third, while Boehner desperately hopes you have a short memory, his references to the 1980s and 1990s overlooks the fact that neither party ever held the debt-ceiling hostage before. Before 2011, the notion of American policymakers threatening to crash the economy on purpose unless their demands were met was considered so hopelessly insane that neither party dared go that far.

Boehner wants to talk about the Reagan, Bush, and Clinton eras? That’s a great idea – let’s talk about the fact that Republicans of these eras were open to concessions as part of budget compromises, and never once said they were prepared to trash the full faith and credit of the United States on purpose unless they got their way.

What Boehner wants to present as routine is, as a matter of reality, wholly outside the traditions of the American experiment. He’s the first Speaker to ever make this threat, so he should hardly be surprised when President Obama balks at paying a ransom to encourage lawmakers to do what they have to do anyway.

As Jon Chait recently explained, “Part of the confusion is that the debt ceiling used to be an opportunity for the opposing party to denounce the fiscal irresponsibility of the president. On occasion, but not usually, debt-ceiling hikes have been appended onto budget agreements that were negotiated on their own terms. What’s completely novel is Congress using the threat of a debt default to force the president to make unilateral policy concessions. The conventions of he-said, she-said journalism have allowed this radical development to insinuate itself into the routine backdrop of partisan squabbling.”

The Republicans’ favorite argument is garbage. Whether they’re aware of this or not is unclear, but either way, it’s not to be taken seriously.

Debt and John Boehner

The worst debt-ceiling talking point of them all

Updated