Wisconsin highlights Donald Trump’s loose grip on the nomination


Donald Trump’s path to the GOP presidential nomination got a little narrower on Tuesday as Senator Ted Cruz handily defeated him in Wisconsin.

“Tonight is a turning point,” Cruz told supporters. “It is a rallying cry. It is a call from the hard-working men and women of Wisconsin to the people of America: We have a choice.”

At 1:15 a.m. ET on Wednesday, NBC News reported that Cruz won 33 of the state’s 42 delegates, with Trump taking three delegates. Two districts had yet to be allocated.

4/5/16, 10:33 PM ET

Watch Ted Cruz's full primary night speech

Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz addresses supporters after his primary victory in Wisconsin.
The difference matters because Trump’s margin of error to win the nomination is getting extremely small.  Each candidate needs 1,237 delegates to clinch it before the convention in July and it’s still plausible Trump gets there. Anything short of that, however, and Cruz becomes the favorite to win at convention, at which the complicated state-by-state delegate selection process means many of Trump’s delegates are unlikely to support him past the first ballot.

Betting markets now give Trump less than 50 percent chance of carrying the party standard into the general election, mainly due to his expected weakness in a contested convention.

Cruz used his remarks in Wisconsin to prepare supporters for a long war that would unlikely to be settled before July.

“Either before Cleveland or at the convention in Cleveland, together we will win a majority of the delegates and together we will beat Hillary Clinton in November,” Cruz said.

Trump, by contrast, warned of a shadowy conspiracy by unnamed opponents within the party to derail his campaign at the convention.

RELATED: Republicans consider advantage of ‘losing with Cruz’

“Ted Cruz is worse than a puppet – he is a Trojan horse, being used by the party bosses attempting to steal the nomination from Mr. Trump,” the Trump campaign said in a statement responding to the Wisconsin results.

In the same statement, the campaign accused Cruz, without any evidence, of illegally coordinating with super PACs opposed to Trump.

A major question now is whether Wisconsin, which some analysts saw as a weak state for Trump to begin with, was a predictable bump in the road for the front-runner or a sign of things to come. The race turns to the Northeast and Trump’s home state of New York on April 19, where recent polling shows him with a massive lead, while Cruz’s best natural states have mostly already voted.

In the meantime, there was plenty for Cruz to like in the exit polls on Tuesday night. He performed unusually well with groups where Trump has often dominated, namely voters without a college degree (winning 48 percent to Trump’s 38 percent) and non-evangelical voters (43 percent to Trump’s 35 percent). 

The Rachel Maddow Show, 4/5/16, 11:19 PM ET

Tight math still allows for Trump win

Steve Kornacki shows the narrow but not impossible national Republican delegate math whereby Donald Trump could still clinch the Republican nomination with 1237 delegates.
In another encouraging sign for Cruz, Ohio Gov. John Kasich underperformed the polls and won no delegates. Cruz has called on Kasich to drop out for weeks, out of fear he’ll divide the anti-Trump vote, especially in upcoming states in the Northeast and Pacific Northwest. Kasich’s weak showing in Wisconsin offered hope that he might fade on his own. 

After weeks of brutal press about Trump’s attacks on Cruz’s wife, his flip flop on “punishment” for women who seek an abortion and his campaign manager’s arrest for alleged battery against a female reporter, the results showed almost no noticeable gender gap. Cruz won men 48-35 over Trump and women 49-34.

It was a stark contrast to general election polling, where Trump’s negatives with women are hitting catastrophic levels relative to his support from men.

For Republicans trying to build to winning national coalition with a clear governing agenda, the exit polls once again showed the deep divisions that will be difficult to reconcile regardless of who wins the nomination.

RELATED: Obama: Cruz’s proposals just as ‘Draconian’ as Trump’s

If Trump secures it, 19 percent of Wisconsin voters said they would vote for a third party candidate, 10 percent said they would vote for Hillary Clinton, and 8 percent said they would not vote. The numbers were similar when asked if Cruz won the nomination: 18 percent of voters Tuesday said they would go third party, 6 percent said they would vote for Clinton and 6 percent said they would stay home.

A whopping 58 percent of voters in the GOP primary said they would be “concerned” or “scared” if Trump won the presidency. The distrust was mutual: 37 percent said the same of Cruz and 47 percent of Kasich.

One thing that’s clear: Republican leaders will face a skeptical audience as they try to smooth things over come convention time. 52 percent of all voters in Tuesday’s primary said they felt “betrayed” by GOP politicians.

Hardball with Chris Matthews, 4/5/16, 10:04 PM ET

Wisconsin results effectively blocks Trump

Conservative talk show host Charlie Sykes talks about the conversations within the Republican Party about how the Wisconsin results effectively block Donald Trump from from becoming the GOP nominee and that the current frontrunner isn’t a true representat

Wisconsin highlights Donald Trump’s loose grip on the nomination