Protesters carry placards outside an Apple store in Boston, Feb. 23, 2016.
Photo by Steven Senne/AP

Prosecutors renew request for Apple to open iPhone in Brooklyn case

The Justice Department Monday asked a federal judge to force Apple to help investigators open the iPhone of a suspected Brooklyn drug dealer.

Prosecutors are seeking to overturn last week’s ruling from a federal magistrate denying the government’s request. Monday’s step is, in essence, the first step in an appeal.

RELATED: Apple doesn’t have to help in NY iPhone case, judge says

“In light of the debate that has recently come to surround this issue, it is worth briefly noting what this case is not about. Apple is not being asked to do anything it does not currently have the capability to do,” the Justice Department’s court filing said.

The Brooklyn case involves an older model device, an iPhone 5s, running an older version of the operating system, iOS 7. For that reason, prosecutors said, Apple is not required to write new software to allow investigators to unlock the phone.

This is a substantial difference from the controversy over the iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino attackers, which was running iOS 8. In order to allow FBI agents to try thousands of combinations of passcodes to open that device, Apple would have to install new software to disable the security functions on the phone.

Andrea Mitchell Reports, 2/17/16, 12:30 PM ET

Apple CEO fights order to unlock shooter’s iPhone

Apple CEO Tim Cook is in a heated standoff with the government after a judge ordered him to unlock an iPhone used by one of the San Bernardino shooters. NBC’s Justice Correspondent Pete Williams joins Andrea Mitchell to explain this privacy versus…

The company has argued that such a step would create a “master key,” jeopardizing the security of millions of iPhones worldwide.

In the Brooklyn case, by contrast, no such new software would be required.

“Apple may perform the passcode-bypass in its own lab, using its own technicians, just as it always has, without revealing to the government how it did so. Therefore, granting the application will not affect the technological security of any Apple iPhone nor hand the government a ‘master key,’” the government’s brief said.

Apple’s lawyers said last month that they have consistently agreed to extract data from older locked phones when served with a lawful court order. But the company stopped doing so after the magistrate judge in Brooklyn last October questioned the court procedure used by the Justice Department.

Lawyers for Apple have not yet responded to the government’s new request.

This story originally appeared on

Apple and Justice Department

Prosecutors renew request for Apple to open iPhone in Brooklyn case