President Barack Obama meets with NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, April 4, 2016. 
Photo by Jacquelyn Martin/AP

Analysis: Obama counters Trump criticism on NATO

When NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg emerged from his meeting with President Obama, it didn’t take long for reporters to ask a question about Donald Trump.

The GOP presidential front-runner has questioned why NATO even still exists. Trump has dismissed the 28-nation alliance as “obsolete,” and designed to fight an enemy that doesn’t exist anymore, the Soviet Union.

Stoltenberg, a seasoned Norwegian politician, politely demurred from weighing in on U.S. politics. Then he jumped to NATO’s defense, pointing out among other things, that NATO has been a steadfast U.S. ally in Afghanistan since the attacks of September 11th, until now.

Some of President Obama’s comments about NATO also could perhaps be viewed as a not so subtle swipe at Trump.

“The NATO alliance is the lynchpin, the cornerstone of our collective defense,” the president said in his Oval Office remarks.

Continuing what have become almost daily broadsides, the president recently said Trump doesn’t know much about foreign policy, or “the world generally.” That came after Trump had said Japan and South Korea should perhaps have nuclear weapons to defend themselves.

MSNBC Live, 4/1/16, 6:26 PM ET

Obama on Trump's nuke comments

President Obama responds to Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump’s recent suggestion that it could be time to change our nuclear policy as it relates to Japan and South Korea.

The president’s meeting with Stoltenberg was planned months ago, White House officials said, but it took on greater urgency because of the attacks in Brussels last month in the European capital where NATO is headquartered.

Obama said the session reinforced “the importance of us staying focused on ISIL and countering the terrorism that has seeped up into Europe and around the world.”

While NATO isn’t a member of the U.S.-led coalition fighting ISIS, most of its individual members like Great Britain, France and Turkey, to name a few, are.

The president also highlighted a number of other global challenges where NATO continues to play a role.

For example, working with members Greece and Turkey to deal with the humanitarian crisis caused by the exodus of Syrian refugees. NATO also continues to back Ukraine where Russia has captured territory in Crimea.

Meanwhile, for all the criticism Trump has taken for his recent foreign policy pronouncements, he did raise an issue about NATO that echoes an Obama administration concern.

MTP Daily, 4/1/16, 5:00 PM ET

What is Trump's Foreign Policy?

Donald Trump’s terrible week could have been even worse if there had been a bigger focus on his foreign policy statements. Chuck Todd looks at some of the candidate’s most surprising comments with Colum Lynch of Foreign Policy.

Many of NATO’s members do not spend as much in their defense and military budgets as the U.S. would like, at least 2 percent. In a recent interview, the president even went so far as to call some U.S. allies “free riders.”

At a recent rally in Wisconsin, using a familiar phrase, Trump accused those NATO members of, “ripping off the US.” Trump went on to say that if those members didn’t pay up, he would be okay with NATO breaking up.

On Monday, Obama’s spokesman struck a more diplomatic tone when asked if the President was satisfied with spending levels now.

“There are some NATO countries that meet that and some that don’t,” Josh Earnest said.

Bottom line: While President Obama strives to make it clear that America’s relationship with NATO is essential, Trump continues to insist it’s not. 

This article originally appeared on

Barack Obama, Donald Trump and Foreign Policy

Analysis: Obama counters Trump criticism on NATO